Please remove reference to JEP 220 from the JSR 376 charter
Dear Experts, JSR 376 will define a cross-vendor standard. But its charter mentions JEP 220, i. e. a pure OpenJDK-specific feature, as a contribution, with the literal words 'The format of JDK binary images is being upgraded to accommodate modules (JEP 220).' (not that it does not say "The format of OpenJDK" but "of JDK"). This is misleading. Unbiased readers could interpret this as JEP 220's disk structure becoming a mandatory part of Java SE 9, hence has to be copied by all compliant JDKs. This in fact it is not the case. As the final standard defined by JSR 376 is not assumed to restrict the on-disk layout of other vendors' JDKs, the reference to JEP 220 should be omitted from the charter page ASAP or the reference has to be clearly marked as definitively not part of the final specification, as it has nothing to do with the final specification's content provided under JSR 376. This already has lead to confusion and discussion between me, Oracle and Apache, hence I plea for an edit. Regards -Markus
participants (1)
-
Markus Karg