Makefile help: setting HOTSPOT_EXTRA_SYSDEFS

[Martin Buchholz]

I'm pasting in the relevant section from the GNU make manual,
hoping it helps.

5.7.2 Communicating Variables to a Sub-`make'
---------------------------------------------

Variable values of the top-level `make' can be passed to the sub-`make'
through the environment by explicit request.  These variables are
defined in the sub-`make' as defaults, but do not override what is
specified in the makefile used by the sub-`make' makefile unless you
use the `-e' switch (*note Summary of Options: Options Summary.).

   To pass down, or "export", a variable, `make' adds the variable and
its value to the environment for running each command.  The sub-`make',
in turn, uses the environment to initialize its table of variable
values.  *Note Variables from the Environment: Environment.

   Except by explicit request, `make' exports a variable only if it is
either defined in the environment initially or set on the command line,
and if its name consists only of letters, numbers, and underscores.
Some shells cannot cope with environment variable names consisting of
characters other than letters, numbers, and underscores.

   The value of the `make' variable `SHELL' is not exported.  Instead,
the value of the `SHELL' variable from the invoking environment is
passed to the sub-`make'.  You can force `make' to export its value for
`SHELL' by using the `export' directive, described below.  *Note
Choosing the Shell::.

   The special variable `MAKEFLAGS' is always exported (unless you
unexport it).  `MAKEFILES' is exported if you set it to anything.

   `make' automatically passes down variable values that were defined
on the command line, by putting them in the `MAKEFLAGS' variable.
*Note Options/Recursion::.

   Variables are _not_ normally passed down if they were created by
default by `make' (*note Variables Used by Implicit Rules: Implicit
Variables.).  The sub-`make' will define these for itself.

   If you want to export specific variables to a sub-`make', use the
`export' directive, like this:

     export VARIABLE ...

If you want to _prevent_ a variable from being exported, use the
`unexport' directive, like this:

     unexport VARIABLE ...

In both of these forms, the arguments to `export' and `unexport' are
expanded, and so could be variables or functions which expand to a
(list of) variable names to be (un)exported.

   As a convenience, you can define a variable and export it at the same
time by doing:

     export VARIABLE = value

has the same result as:

     VARIABLE = value
     export VARIABLE

and

     export VARIABLE := value

has the same result as:

     VARIABLE := value
     export VARIABLE

   Likewise,

     export VARIABLE += value

is just like:

     VARIABLE += value
     export VARIABLE

*Note Appending More Text to Variables: Appending.

   You may notice that the `export' and `unexport' directives work in
`make' in the same way they work in the shell, `sh'.

   If you want all variables to be exported by default, you can use
`export' by itself:

     export

This tells `make' that variables which are not explicitly mentioned in
an `export' or `unexport' directive should be exported.  Any variable
given in an `unexport' directive will still _not_ be exported.  If you
use `export' by itself to export variables by default, variables whose
names contain characters other than alphanumerics and underscores will
not be exported unless specifically mentioned in an `export' directive.

   The behavior elicited by an `export' directive by itself was the
default in older versions of GNU `make'.  If your makefiles depend on
this behavior and you want to be compatible with old versions of
`make', you can write a rule for the special target
`.EXPORT_ALL_VARIABLES' instead of using the `export' directive.  This
will be ignored by old `make's, while the `export' directive will cause
a syntax error.

   Likewise, you can use `unexport' by itself to tell `make' _not_ to
export variables by default.  Since this is the default behavior, you
would only need to do this if `export' had been used by itself earlier
(in an included makefile, perhaps).  You *cannot* use `export' and
`unexport' by themselves to have variables exported for some commands
and not for others.  The last `export' or `unexport' directive that
appears by itself determines the behavior for the entire run of `make'.

   As a special feature, the variable `MAKELEVEL' is changed when it is
passed down from level to level.  This variable's value is a string
which is the depth of the level as a decimal number.  The value is `0'
for the top-level `make'; `1' for a sub-`make', `2' for a
sub-sub-`make', and so on.  The incrementation happens when `make' sets
up the environment for a command.

   The main use of `MAKELEVEL' is to test it in a conditional directive
(*note Conditional Parts of Makefiles: Conditionals.); this way you can
write a makefile that behaves one way if run recursively and another
way if run directly by you.

   You can use the variable `MAKEFILES' to cause all sub-`make'
commands to use additional makefiles.  The value of `MAKEFILES' is a
whitespace-separated list of file names.  This variable, if defined in
the outer-level makefile, is passed down through the environment; then
it serves as a list of extra makefiles for the sub-`make' to read
before the usual or specified ones.  *Note The Variable `MAKEFILES':
MAKEFILES Variable.



On Tue, Jun 15, 2010 at 18:27, David Holmes <David.Holmes at oracle.com> wrote:
> I originally asked this internally to my HS colleagues but alas no solution.
> Any Make gurus out there? ;-)
>
> A further note: the obvious reason for this to fail would be because
> defs.make is not processed before launching the buildtree.make sub-make, but
> AFAICS it is processed.
>
> Thanks,
> David
>
> David Holmes said the following on 06/15/10 19:14:
>>
>> If I set HOTSPOT_EXTRA_SYSDEFS in the environment or pass it as a variable
>> to the top-level make invocation then it works fine and buildtree.make will
>> see it and use it in the makefiles that it generates.
>>
>> However, I want to set it in the top-level defs.make based on some other
>> values. I do that and export it so that submakes will see it - but they
>> don't: buildtree.make sees HOTSPOT_EXTRA_SYSDEFS as empty.
>>
>> I've tried setting it using += and := but they both fail to set it for the
>> sub-make.
>>
>> Using "make -d" is no help at all as it doesn't show how it evaluates
>> things (the way sh -x does). :(
>>
>> Does anybody know how I can set this?
>>
>> Thanks,
>> David
>