RFR: 8004518 & 8010122 : Default methods on Map

[Ulf Zibis]

Am 12.04.2013 23:36, schrieb Mike Duigou:
> On Apr 11 2013, at 15:15 , Ulf Zibis wrote:
>
>> There is still a yoda style in ConcurrentMap line 72, HashMap line 361
> Fixed

I still see no change in webrev 5 in HashMap line 361

>
>> To be in line with old habits, please remove space after casts. See also: http://bugs.sun.com/bugdatabase/view_bug.do?bug_id=6939278
> I am not going to do this.

Well in Hashtable, existing code doesn't have the space after cast. If you insert space in new code, 
you introduce an inconsistency in style. Even your new code is inconsistent, compare:
HashTable line 917, 938, 984 etc.
HashMap line 588 etc.
Collections line 1402 etc.

I also notice, you introduce a new style ? in for( ; ... ; ... ;) expressions with space before ';'.

>> Collections:
>> lines 1442... + 3900... , indentation for follow up line should be 8

There are still lines 976, 1062

>> Map:
>> lines 599..600 bad indentation
> Corrected.

Hm, I see still 3 instead 4 spaces and also in lines 545..546

>
>> Use consistent formatted code examples in javadoc. I like the style from lines 567 to 570, but e.g. from line 622 to 626:
>> - 2 spaces before <pre>
>> - indentation should be 4
>> - line break before }</pre>
> I had left these along in the previous round. Should be fixed now.

Great, but see also code samples in ConcurrentMap.


-Ulf