RFR: JDK-8259395 Patching automatic module with additional packages re-creates module without "requires java.base" [v3]

[Johannes Kuhn]

On Tue, 19 Jan 2021 16:14:51 GMT, Alan Bateman <alanb at openjdk.org> wrote:

>>> 
>>> 
>>> This issue requires a Reviewer from someone working in this area. Please do not sponsor or integrate until that review has been done.
>> 
>> Ok, increased the number of required reviewers to 2.  
>> Hope that was the right move, as I don't see any other way to undo /integrate.
>
> Finally getting back to this. The update to ModulePatcher.java is good. Test coverage needs discussion. There are four scenarios where test coverage is lacking:
> 
> 1. automatic module on the module path, patched to override or augment classes/resources
> 2. automatic module on the module path, patched to add new packages
> 3. automatic module as the initial module, patched to override or augment classes/resources
> 4. automatic module as the initial module, patched to add new packages
> 
> The patch adds automatic/PatchTest.java so it's adding test coverage for 4. We should probably rename it to leave room for the other tests, or else create it so that additional test coverage can be added. I assume the test was copied from another test as there are a few left overs, e.g. `@modules java.script` but the test does not use this module. I don't want to expand the scope of this PR too much but I think we should at least cover 3 and 4 in the test.

Thanks @AlanBateman, I now implemented a few more tests.  
They should cover all four cases you described.

-------------

PR: https://git.openjdk.java.net/jdk/pull/2000