Fwd: Scene 3D objects throw exception on Android deivces

Tue Aug 6 09:43:46 UTC 2024

Hi,

Sorry I subscribed to the discuss mailing list under the wrong email
address, I have resubscribed and am resubmitting the below post.  After
reading other posts on the forum I was wondering if this might be due to a
lack of 3D support on embedded (although this is an Android device).  I
have tried modifying the javafx.platform.properties by
setting android.com.sun.javafx.isEmbedded=false
or com.sun.javafx.experimental.embedded.3d=true but neither have any
effect.  Is there anything else I can do?

Thanks

---------- Forwarded message ---------
From: Ashley Hales <ashley.hales at gmail.com>
Date: Tue, 25 Jun 2024 at 11:39
Subject: Scene 3D objects throw exception on Android deivces
To: <discuss at openjdk.java.net>

Hi, I have been compiling a JavaFX app for Android using the Dalvik SDK. I
have managed to resolve all the dependencies and compiled into an APK. This
APK will install on Android devices but doesn't work on all of them. I have
tried it on a number of devices, some display fine but some just show a
black screen.

I have modified the HelloWorld app included with the Dalvik SDK by changing
the code to debug my problem. It works on all of my devices with just a
label on the screen but as soon as I add a sphere into the scene it just
displays a black screen on some devices. I have searched on the internet
and suggestions indicate that this may be a memory issue but I have tried
setting android.monocle.stacksize = 12800 in the javafx.platform.properties
but this has had no effect. I have also tried printing out the result of
Platform.isSupported(ConditionalFeature.SCENE3D) but confusingly this shows
true despite the error.
I have tested on a couple of devices so far.  The error occurs every time
on my MBOX MINIM8S II (Android 6.0.1) but never on my Samsung Galaxy Table
Model SM-T230 (Android 4.4.2)  device.  I do not have any Pixel/Nexus
devices to test the app on.  The Build number on my MBOX is "p212-userdebug
6.0.1 MHC19J 20161013 test-keys".

I have also shared the compiled APK on Google Drive which you may access
from
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1QLA21gg2g9-ODrKctSqac6pNC2cxzCtx/view?usp=drive_link
.

Here is the logcat report for the issue…

05-12 09:10:06.584 4053 4181 I ActivityManager: Start proc
8921:org.javafxports.helloworld/u0a56 for activity
org.javafxports.helloworld/javafxports.android.FXActivity
05-12 09:10:06.649 8921 8921 I art : Not late-enabling -Xcheck:jni (already
on)
05-12 09:10:06.731 8921 8921 I MultiDex: VM with version 2.1.0 has multidex
support
05-12 09:10:06.731 8921 8921 I MultiDex: install
05-12 09:10:06.731 8921 8921 I MultiDex: VM has multidex support, MultiDex
support library is disabled.
05-12 09:10:06.735 8921 8921 V FXActivity: Initializing JavaFX Platform,
using 8.60.9-SNAPSHOT
05-12 09:10:06.745 8921 8921 V FXActivity native: Loading JavaFXDalvik
library
05-12 09:10:06.751 8921 8921 I System.out: usetextureview = false,
useswipekeyboard = false
05-12 09:10:06.753 8921 8921 V FXActivity: onCreate called, using
8.60.9-SNAPSHOT
05-12 09:10:06.754 8921 8934 V FXActivity native: Notification queue
instance created.
05-12 09:10:06.754 8921 8934 V FXActivity native: Notification queue started
05-12 09:10:06.758 4172 4172 V PhoneStatusBar: setLightsOn(true)
05-12 09:10:06.789 8921 8921 V FXActivity native: appDataDir:
/data/user/0/org.javafxports.helloworld
05-12 09:10:06.790 8921 8921 V FXActivity: onStart
05-12 09:10:06.790 8921 8921 V FXActivity: onResume
05-12 09:10:06.827 8921 8921 V FXEntity: Surface created.
05-12 09:10:06.828 8921 8921 V FXActivity native: [JVDBG] SURFACE created
native android window at 0xf4a94608, surface = 0xffda7390
05-12 09:10:06.970 8921 8921 I System.out: user.locale=en-US
05-12 09:10:06.970 8921 8921 I System.out: monocle.stackSize=128000
05-12 09:10:06.970 8921 8921 I System.out: prism.text=native
05-12 09:10:06.970 8921 8921 I System.out: java.vendor.url=
http://www.android.com/
05-12 09:10:06.970 8921 8921 I System.out: java.ext.dirs=
05-12 09:10:06.970 8921 8921 I System.out: line.separator=
05-12 09:10:06.970 8921 8921 I System.out: file.encoding=UTF-8
05-12 09:10:06.970 8921 8921 I System.out: java.runtime.version=0.9
05-12 09:10:06.970 8921 8921 I System.out: prism.dirtyopts=true
05-12 09:10:06.970 8921 8921 I System.out: user.name=root
05-12 09:10:06.970 8921 8921 I System.out: monocle.input.touchRadius=1
05-12 09:10:06.970 8921 8921 I System.out: java.compiler=
05-12 09:10:06.970 8921 8921 I System.out: android.icu.unicode.version=7.0
05-12 09:10:06.970 8921 8921 I System.out: prism.debugfonts=true
05-12 09:10:06.970 8921 8921 I System.out: java.version=0
05-12 09:10:06.970 8921 8921 I System.out: android.icu.library.version=55.1
05-12 09:10:06.970 8921 8921 I System.out: use.egl=true
05-12 09:10:06.971 8921 8921 I System.out: embedded=monocle
05-12 09:10:06.971 8921 8921 I System.out: prism.lcdtext=false
05-12 09:10:06.971 8921 8921 I System.out: os.arch=armv8l
05-12 09:10:06.971 8921 8921 I System.out:
java.io.tmpdir=/data/user/0/org.javafxports.hellowor...
05-12 09:10:06.971 8921 8921 I System.out: glass.platform=Monocle
05-12 09:10:06.971 8921 8921 I System.out: android.zlib.version=1.2.8
05-12 09:10:06.971 8921 8921 I System.out: user.language=en
05-12 09:10:06.971 8921 8921 I System.out: java.vm.version=2.1.0
05-12 09:10:06.971 8921 8921 I System.out: com.sun.javafx.isEmbedded=true
05-12 09:10:06.971 8921 8921 I System.out: prism.glDepthSize=16
05-12 09:10:06.971 8921 8921 I System.out: path.separator=:
05-12 09:10:06.971 8921 8921 I System.out: java.runtime.name=Android Runtime
05-12 09:10:06.971 8921 8921 I System.out: java.specification.version=0.9
05-12 09:10:06.971 8921 8921 I System.out: user.dir=/
05-12 09:10:06.971 8921 8921 I System.out: prism.maxTextureSize=2048
05-12 09:10:06.971 8921 8921 I System.out: java.vm.specification.vendor=The
Android Project
05-12 09:10:06.971 8921 8921 I System.out: java.vm.name=Dalvik
05-12 09:10:06.971 8921 8921 I System.out: monocle.platform=Android
05-12 09:10:06.971 8921 8921 I System.out: log.lens=FINEST
05-12 09:10:06.971 8921 8921 I System.out: java.vm.specification.version=0.9
05-12 09:10:06.971 8921 8921 I System.out: user.home=
05-12 09:10:06.971 8921 8921 I System.out: java.specification.name=Dalvik
Core Library
05-12 09:10:06.971 8921 8921 I System.out: file.separator=/
05-12 09:10:06.971 8921 8921 I System.out:
java.library.path=/vendor/lib:/system/lib
05-12 09:10:06.971 8921 8921 I System.out: user.variant=
05-12 09:10:06.971 8921 8921 I System.out: os.version=3.14.29
05-12 09:10:06.971 8921 8921 I System.out:
java.boot.class.path=/system/framework/core-libart.jar:/sy...
05-12 09:10:06.971 8921 8921 I System.out: DALVIK.prism.verbose=true
05-12 09:10:06.971 8921 8921 I System.out: java.vm.specification.name=Dalvik
Virtual Machine Specification
05-12 09:10:06.971 8921 8921 I System.out: javafx.platform=android
05-12 09:10:06.971 8921 8921 I System.out: glass.lens=eglfb
05-12 09:10:06.971 8921 8921 I System.out: os.name=Linux
05-12 09:10:06.971 8921 8921 I System.out: user.region=US
05-12 09:10:06.971 8921 8921 I System.out: java.class.path=.
05-12 09:10:06.971 8921 8921 I System.out:
android.icu.impl.ICUBinary.dataPath=/data/misc/zoneinfo/current/icu:/syst...
05-12 09:10:06.971 8921 8921 I System.out: prism.verbose=true
05-12 09:10:06.971 8921 8921 I System.out: prism.vsync=false
05-12 09:10:06.971 8921 8921 I System.out: java.specification.vendor=The
Android Project
05-12 09:10:06.971 8921 8921 I System.out: java.vm.vendor=The Android
Project
05-12 09:10:06.971 8921 8921 I System.out: prism.allowhidpi=false
05-12 09:10:06.972 8921 8921 I System.out: java.vendor=The Android Project
05-12 09:10:06.972 8921 8921 I System.out: http.agent=Dalvik/2.1.0 (Linux;
U; Android 6.0.1...
05-12 09:10:06.972 8921 8921 I System.out: android.icu.cldr.version=27.0.1
05-12 09:10:06.972 8921 8921 I System.out: android.openssl.version=BoringSSL
05-12 09:10:06.972 8921 8921 I System.out: java.home=/system
05-12 09:10:06.972 8921 8921 I System.out: java.vm.vendor.url=
http://www.android.com/
05-12 09:10:06.972 8921 8921 I System.out: java.class.version=50.0
05-12 09:10:06.972 8921 8921 V DalvikLauncher: Launch JavaFX application on
DALVIK vm.
05-12 09:10:06.976 8921 8921 V DalvikLauncher: We have JavaFX on our
current (base) classpath, registered exit listener
05-12 09:10:06.978 8921 8921 V DalvikLauncher: application class: [class
org.javafxports.helloworld.HelloAndroid]
05-12 09:10:06.978 8921 8921 V DalvikLauncher: preloader class: [null]
05-12 09:10:06.978 8921 8921 V DalvikLauncher: javafx application class:
[class javafx.application.Application]
05-12 09:10:06.978 8921 8921 V DalvikLauncher: javafx launcher class:
[class com.sun.javafx.application.LauncherImpl]
05-12 09:10:06.978 8921 8921 V DalvikLauncher: launch application method:
[public static void
com.sun.javafx.application.LauncherImpl.launchApplication(java.lang.Class,java.lang.Class,java.lang.String[])]
05-12 09:10:06.979 8921 8921 V FXEntity: Called Surface changed [1280,
696], format 4
05-12 09:10:06.979 8921 8921 V FXActivity native: [JVDBG] SURFACE created
native android window at 0xf4a94608, surface = 0xffda7370
05-12 09:10:06.980 8921 8921 V FXEntity: Called Surface redraw needed
05-12 09:10:06.989 8921 8921 V FXEntity: Called Surface redraw needed
05-12 09:10:07.018 4053 4075 I ActivityManager: Displayed
org.javafxports.helloworld/javafxports.android.FXActivity: +461ms
05-12 09:10:07.020 8921 8938 I System.out: Prism pipeline init order: es2
05-12 09:10:07.020 8921 8938 I System.out: Using native-based Pisces
rasterizer
05-12 09:10:07.020 8921 8938 I System.out: Using dirty region optimizations
05-12 09:10:07.020 8921 8938 I System.out: Using system sized mask for
primitives
05-12 09:10:07.021 8921 8938 I System.out: Not forcing power of 2 sizes for
textures
05-12 09:10:07.021 8921 8938 I System.out: Using hardware CLAMP_TO_ZERO mode
05-12 09:10:07.021 8921 8938 I System.out: Not opting in for HiDPI pixel
scaling
05-12 09:10:07.026 8921 8939 I System.out: Prism pipeline name =
com.sun.prism.es2.ES2Pipeline
05-12 09:10:07.029 8921 8939 I System.out: Loading ES2 native library ...
prism_es2_monocle
05-12 09:10:07.039 8921 8939 I System.out: succeeded.
05-12 09:10:07.040 8921 8939 I System.out: GLFactory using
com.sun.prism.es2.MonocleGLFactory
05-12 09:10:07.052 8921 8939 I GLASS : I have to Call dlopen libGLESv2.so
05-12 09:10:07.052 8921 8939 I GLASS : handle = 0xf712dd04
05-12 09:10:07.052 8921 8939 I GLASS : I have to Call dlopen libEGL.so
05-12 09:10:07.052 8921 8939 I GLASS : handle = 0xf712d9c4
05-12 09:10:07.053 8921 8939 I GLASS : Binding to libactivity.so
05-12 09:10:07.054 8921 8939 I GLASS : GetNativeWindow = 0xf4ad86dc,
getDensitiy = 0xf4ad86ec
05-12 09:10:07.054 8921 8935 V FXEntity: notify_glassHasStarted called in
FXActivity. register device now.
05-12 09:10:07.072 8921 8939 E libEGL : eglMakeCurrent:800 error 3009
(EGL_BAD_MATCH)
05-12 09:10:07.076 8921 8939 I System.out: (X) Got class = class
com.sun.prism.es2.ES2Pipeline
05-12 09:10:07.077 8921 8939 I System.out: Initialized prism pipeline:
com.sun.prism.es2.ES2Pipeline
05-12 09:10:07.083 8921 8943 I DENSITY : GETDENSITY, answer = 1.000000
05-12 09:10:07.097 8921 8939 I System.out: Maximum supported texture size:
4096
05-12 09:10:07.097 8921 8939 I System.out: Maximum texture size clamped to
2048
05-12 09:10:07.097 8921 8939 I System.out: Non power of two texture support
= true
05-12 09:10:07.098 8921 8939 I System.out: Maximum number of vertex
attributes = 16
05-12 09:10:07.098 8921 8939 I System.out: Maximum number of uniform vertex
components = 1024
05-12 09:10:07.098 8921 8939 I System.out: Maximum number of uniform
fragment components = 1024
05-12 09:10:07.098 8921 8939 I System.out: Maximum number of varying
components = 48
05-12 09:10:07.098 8921 8939 I System.out: Maximum number of texture units
usable in a vertex shader = 0
05-12 09:10:07.098 8921 8939 I System.out: Maximum number of texture units
usable in a fragment shader = 8
05-12 09:10:07.098 8921 8939 I System.out: Graphics Vendor: ARM
05-12 09:10:07.098 8921 8939 I System.out: Renderer: Mali-450 MP
05-12 09:10:07.098 8921 8939 I System.out: Version: OpenGL ES 2.0
05-12 09:10:07.104 8921 8935 I System.out: register device done
05-12 09:10:07.107 8921 8943 W System.err: vsync: false vpipe: true
05-12 09:10:07.107 8921 8943 I System.out: [MON] Create device
05-12 09:10:07.109 8921 8943 I System.out: [MON] Create device done, add
done
05-12 09:10:07.257 8921 8943 W System.err: Loading FontFactory
com.sun.javafx.font.freetype.FTFactory
05-12 09:10:07.258 8921 8943 W System.err: Subpixel: enabled
05-12 09:10:07.272 8921 8943 W System.err: Freetype2 Loaded (version 2.10.0)
05-12 09:10:07.272 8921 8943 W System.err: LCD support Enabled
05-12 09:10:07.302 8921 8943 W art : Before Android 4.1, method void
com.sun.javafx.scene.transform.TransformUtils$ImmutableTransform.ensureCanTransform2DPoint()
would have incorrectly overridden the package-private method in
javafx.scene.transform.Transform
05-12 09:10:07.784 8921 8943 W art : Before Android 4.1, method double
javafx.scene.text.TextFlow.computeChildPrefAreaHeight(javafx.scene.Node,
javafx.geometry.Insets) would have incorrectly overridden the
package-private method in javafx.scene.layout.Region
05-12 09:10:07.784 8921 8943 W art : Before Android 4.1, method double
javafx.scene.text.TextFlow.computeChildPrefAreaWidth(javafx.scene.Node,
javafx.geometry.Insets) would have incorrectly overridden the
package-private method in javafx.scene.layout.Region
05-12 09:10:08.001 8921 8939 I System.out: max rectangle texture cell size
= 62
05-12 09:10:08.019 8921 8939 I System.out: wrap rectangle texture = 2 x 2
05-12 09:10:08.024 8921 8939 I System.out: ES2ResourceFactory: Prism -
createStockShader: AlphaTexture_Color.frag
05-12 09:10:08.287 8921 8939 E javafx : Program link log: L0010 Uniform
'color' differ on precision
05-12 09:10:08.287 8921 8939 W System.err: java.lang.RuntimeException:
Error creating shader program
05-12 09:10:08.288 8921 8939 W System.err: at
com.sun.prism.es2.ES2Shader.createFromSource(ES2Shader.java:158)
05-12 09:10:08.288 8921 8939 W System.err: at
com.sun.prism.es2.ES2PhongShader.getShader(ES2PhongShader.java:190)
05-12 09:10:08.288 8921 8939 W System.err: at
com.sun.prism.es2.ES2Context.getPhongShader(ES2Context.java:122)
05-12 09:10:08.288 8921 8939 W System.err: at
com.sun.prism.es2.ES2Context.renderMeshView(ES2Context.java:451)
05-12 09:10:08.288 8921 8939 W System.err: at
com.sun.prism.es2.ES2MeshView.render(ES2MeshView.java:119)
05-12 09:10:08.288 8921 8939 W System.err: at
com.sun.javafx.sg.prism.NGShape3D.renderMeshView(NGShape3D.java:179)
05-12 09:10:08.288 8921 8939 W System.err: at
com.sun.javafx.sg.prism.NGShape3D.renderContent(NGShape3D.java:201)
05-12 09:10:08.288 8921 8939 W System.err: at
com.sun.javafx.sg.prism.NGNode.doRender(NGNode.java:2056)
05-12 09:10:08.288 8921 8939 W System.err: at
com.sun.javafx.sg.prism.NGNode.render(NGNode.java:1948)
05-12 09:10:08.288 8921 8939 W System.err: at
com.sun.javafx.sg.prism.NGGroup.renderContent(NGGroup.java:235)
05-12 09:10:08.288 8921 8939 W System.err: at
com.sun.javafx.sg.prism.NGRegion.renderContent(NGRegion.java:576)
05-12 09:10:08.288 8921 8939 W System.err: at
com.sun.javafx.sg.prism.NGNode.doRender(NGNode.java:2056)
05-12 09:10:08.288 8921 8939 W System.err: at
com.sun.javafx.sg.prism.NGNode.render(NGNode.java:1948)
05-12 09:10:08.288 8921 8939 W System.err: at
com.sun.javafx.tk.quantum.ViewPainter.doPaint(ViewPainter.java:477)
05-12 09:10:08.288 8921 8939 W System.err: at
com.sun.javafx.tk.quantum.ViewPainter.paintImpl(ViewPainter.java:330)
05-12 09:10:08.288 8921 8939 W System.err: at
com.sun.javafx.tk.quantum.PresentingPainter.run(PresentingPainter.java:91)
05-12 09:10:08.288 8921 8939 W System.err: at
java.util.concurrent.Executors$RunnableAdapter.call(Executors.java:423)
05-12 09:10:08.288 8921 8939 W System.err: at
java.util.concurrent.FutureTask.runAndReset(FutureTask.java:278)
05-12 09:10:08.288 8921 8939 W System.err: at
com.sun.javafx.tk.RenderJob.run(RenderJob.java:58)
05-12 09:10:08.288 8921 8939 W System.err: at
java.util.concurrent.ThreadPoolExecutor.runWorker(ThreadPoolExecutor.java:1113)
05-12 09:10:08.288 8921 8939 W System.err: at
java.util.concurrent.ThreadPoolExecutor$Worker.run(ThreadPoolExecutor.java:588)
05-12 09:10:08.288 8921 8939 W System.err: at
com.sun.javafx.tk.quantum.QuantumRenderer$PipelineRunnable.run(QuantumRenderer.java:125)
05-12 09:10:08.288 8921 8939 W System.err: at
java.lang.Thread.run(Thread.java:818)
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <https://mail.openjdk.org/pipermail/discuss/attachments/20240806/c81ef9bd/attachment-0001.htm>