[rfc][icedtea-web] javaws.1 man page update

Jacob Wisor gitne at gmx.de
Sun Aug 24 00:24:06 UTC 2014


On 08/23/2014 07:58 PM, Andrew Azores wrote:
> Hi,
>
> I looked at `man javaws` for some reason yesterday - no idea what I was looking
> for or why - and thought it could do with some minor improvement. I've fixed a
> few minor typos, improved the phrasing in a few areas, and made it more
> consistent with capitalizing acronyms such as XML, HTML, and JNLP.
>
> Thanks,

Yes, IcedTea-Web's documentation does indeed need some overhaul. So, thank you 
for bringing this up.

I have proposed translated man pages *last* year but they have been bluntly 
dismissed because of Jiri's idea of generating those from source code. Well, it 
eludes me to this day how this could be accomplished in a sensible way. I did 
not say it then but I think it is time to say it openly now: Generating sensibly 
translated documentation from source code is a delusion of megalomania (without 
using any AI or fuzzy logic technology). And to be honest, even if it worked I 
really do not see any benefit to it except for making things more complicated. 
What could be easier than editing a bunch of text files? No, we need to reinvent 
the wheel for a dubious purpose and outcome.

So, here we are today... and nothing has happened, even though Jie Kang was the 
last one to touch on this. :-(

To sum it up: Andrew, I would not be surprised if your good and plausible 
modifications to the javaws man page would get dismissed too... because you 
know, it can be generated from the source code... :-\

Jacob


More information about the distro-pkg-dev mailing list