Mercurial repo for openjdk6 drops

[Joseph D. Darcy]

Joseph D. Darcy wrote:
> Joseph D. Darcy wrote:
>> Kelly O'Hair wrote:
>>> Speaking from experience, any attempts at cleanly creating changesets
>>> from TeamWare data alone is a waste of time. Just doesn't work well.
>>> Granted we have pretty complete OpenJDK6 changeset data (data beyond
>>> the TeamWare data) and could potentially do this, it's quite a bit of
>>> grunt work to accomplish. Before we go off on this kind of adventure
>>> we need to make sure the time spent is worth it.
>>> A different approach would be to create changesets per build/promotion,
>>> but those kind of large changesets can have limited usefulness.
>>>
>>> I'll try and talk to Joe about this tomorrow.
>>>
>>> Also, don't forget that the OpenJDK7 sources are a Mercurial forest,
>>> not just one repository. I assume that we want to mimic the same
>>> forest layout, keeping the langtools, corba, jaxp, jaxws, and hotspot
>>> sources in their own repositories, separate from the core 'jdk' 
>>> repository.
>>> That allows us to do some plug and play with these repositories
>>> between OpenJDK6 and OpenJDK7.
>>>
>>> -kto
>> Yes, my thinking has been to mirror the overall JDK 7 repository 
>> forest structure in OpenJDK 6.
>
> Quick follow-up, I've been traveling recently and haven't had a chance 
> to chat with Kelly yet.
>
> Given that there is currently the per-build external Mercurial 
> repository and that it is easy to get the list of bugs fixed in a 
> build, retroactively synthesizing the (approximate) patches associated 
> with a set of bugs *might* be workable since figuring out the bug <-> 
> file mapping shouldn't be that bad.  If those interested in seeing the 
> past history synthesized these patches, I could focus on finishing 
> getting the OpenJDK build 12++ code ready for Mercurial and then 
> reverse apply the set of patches to get back to the earlier public 
> source drops.  However, this might be more work than I think and I'll 
> want to talk to Kelly about the detailed logistics of what would be 
> necessary for this to happen.
>
> My priority is on getting the "official" Mercurial repository up and 
> running so we can collaborate there going forward as opposed to 
> spending lots of time on retrofitting the existing build history into 
> the new repository.
>
> Also, in the future I'd like to consider an infrastructure where areas 
> like corba, jaxp, and jaxws for OpenJDK 6 could be managed as patches 
> to an imported code base rather than having a fully populated copy of 
> the code under revision management for the release.
>
> Cheers,

Kelly and I chatted on Tuesday.  We'll be working on getting the 
official OpenJDK 6 Mercurial repositories up and open for business.

We agreed to publish the future repositories with at least as much 
version information as the one Mark Wielaard setup, that is, at least 
one changeset per build going back to the first published OpenJDK6 
build, b05.  If people would like to see more fine grained changesets 
with more detailed changeset -> bugid grouping, Martin, Mark W., and 
others could help carve up the big build-to-build patches and sent us 
the decomposition before the official Mercurial transitional.  
Alternatively, if that decomposition isn't finished before we want to go 
live with the repositories, Kelly though that adding supplementary 
changsets with this information might be able to be added later.  Kelly, 
please fill in any details here.

In the near term, we will probably have a forest of repositories as in 
JDK 7.  However, longer term I would be happy if only hotspot, jdk, and 
langtools were full repositories and jaxp, jaxws, and corba repos were 
just vestiges that applied a few patches to upstream sources.  We'll 
have to work out some logistical details with the HotSpot team to mesh 
with their "HotSpot Express" release model.

-Joe

The per-build bug lists below are raw lists from the bug database with a 
small amount of filtering to remove a handful of bugs whose changes only 
touch closed JDK code; I might have missed one or two of these bugs 
fixes that aren't present in the open code.

Fixed in b06 - 
http://mail.openjdk.java.net/pipermail/jdk6-dev/2008-February/000016.html

6601458: Move java.math tests from closed to open
6499487: [zh_CN] README_zh_CN in jdk is out of sync with the english README
6566218: l10n of 6476932
6536195: flaw in DatatypeConverter
6536209: flaw in SAAJMetaFactory
6588002: XSLTProcessorApplet still allows reading from forbidden URLs
6587132: Code changes behavior when compiled
6635776: Regression in jaxb tests with JDk6 U4
6559283: Duplicate GPL notices in src/share/classes/com/sun/xml/internal
6590857: Drag & Drop arbitrary file copy
6662775: Move Imaging and color classes from closed to open
6606396: Notepad demo doesn't run in Japanese locale.
6646197: (tz) Support tzdata2007k
6509039: Swedish localization has incorrect am/pm markers in FormatData_sv
6573250: Java.util.Currency.getSymbol(Locale) returns wrong value when 
locale is not US.
6610748: Dateformat - AM-PM indicator in Finnish appears to be from English
6645268: Country/language names with locale fi_FI are incorrect for 
FRANCE/FRENCH
6645405: Errors in Hungarian local-specific formatting. (L10N part of 
6609703)
6650730: Lithuanian locale date and number formats mismatch.
4225362: localized DateFormatSymbols for fr_FR is wrong
6450945: The week day for Saturday and the first week day in Romania 
locale are incorrect
6609737: DateFormat incorrect for German locale
6647063: java/text/Format/NumberFormat/CurrencyFormat.java fails
6652200: test/java/util/TimeZone/Bug6329116.java fails
6598520: (tz) Windows time zone mapping table needs to be updated for 
KB933360
6605798: JAX-WS RI 2.1.1 should be integrated in OpenJDK6
6661448: Make the SNMP agent optional when OPENJDK=true and 
IMPORT_BINARY_PLUGS=false
6662581: jdk/make/common/internal/Defs-corba.gmk doesnot list all files 
to be imported: some classes missing
6667532: Update OpenJDK 6 make/README
6676375: Make sure MOTIF_REQUIRED=false when OPENJDK=true


Fixed in b07 - 
http://mail.openjdk.java.net/pipermail/jdk6-dev/2008-March/000026.html

6586752: Window decorations do not appear
6642034: System.getProperty("os.name") returns Windows Vista on Windows 
Server 2008 (longhorn)
6671051: (process) Runtime.exec() hangs if signalled during fork/exec
6636951: javax.swing.plaf SigTest Failures in OpenJDK 6
6662830: OpenJDK build testing results
6668781: Openjdk windows cygwin build failure: no rule to make 
linker_md.obj target
6669175: Add OpenJDK(TM) notification
6672710: Allow for openjdk sound to be built without the binary plugs 
(IMPORT_BINARY_PLUGS=false)
6672777: Broken deploy build from jdk fix 6668781 for cygwin windows
6674015: Update trademark notification to version 1.1
6674314: Setting MOTIF_REQUIRED to 'false' doesn't work


Fixed in b08 - 
http://mail.openjdk.java.net/pipermail/jdk6-dev/2008-March/000033.html

6613927: Compilation of splashscreen png library failed on Ubuntu 7.04 
(64bit)
6578538: com.sun.crypto.provider.SunJCE instance leak using KRB5 and 
LoginContext
6679296: sec-lib.zip and friends inadvertantly added to the 6-open and 
jdk7 b19 directories
6679994: Undocumented  .jar files in JDK 6 Open:  
hotspot/agent/src/share/lib
6680088: SSLEngineDeadlock workaround for 6519515 needed by OpenJDK builds


Fixed b09 - 
http://mail.openjdk.java.net/pipermail/jdk6-dev/2008-April/000039.html

6602007: Transition to Mercurial:  Remove SCCS keywords from files in 
the test/ directory
6633656: Cross platform print dialog doesn't check for orientation being 
unsupported.
6672868: Package javax.xml.ws.wsaddressing not included in 
make/docs/CORE_PKGS.gmk
6650748: (tz) Java runtime doesn't detect VET time zone correctly on Windows
6679340: (tz) Support tzdata2008b
6678161: Printing to remote non-Postscript printer does not work in Linux


Fixed in b10 - 
http://mail.openjdk.java.net/pipermail/jdk6-dev/2008-May/000058.html

6683078: Update JCE framework and provider builds to work on read-only 
filesystems
6604044: java crashes talking to second X screen
6684582: Launcher needs improved error reporting
6644659: Error in default target of make/javax/crypto in OpenJDK build
6691185: (coll) TreeMap.navigableKeySet's descendingIterator method 
starts at first instead of last entry
6691215: (coll) IdentityHashMap.containsValue(null) returns true when 
null value not present
6523403: OSS CMM: Need to provide lcms library with PYCC and LINEAR_RGB 
OS ICC profiles
6682167: Add cygwin faq to README-builds.html
6695553: Cleanup GPLv2+SPL legal notices in hat sources
6563616: Clarify instructions for unpacking openjdk binary "plug"
6611685: Incorrect link to CA certs info from build README
6597857: JDK build instructions need to be updated 
(BUILD_JDK_IMPORT_PATH, BUILD_BINARY_PLUGS_PATH)
6636469: Java Fullscreen Exclusive Mode not working with Xorg server 
1.3.0 and above
6602426: TEST_BUG: test/sun/misc/Version/VersionCheck.java fails
6479286: LTP: XMLEncoder does not persist LineBorder properly
6673853: LegacyIntrospectorTest is testing an old deprecated com.sun API 
not present in OpenJDK.
6707643: (tz) Support tzdata2008c
6702956: OpenJDK: replace encumbered code (software synthesizer)
6703931: Remove jaxws doc-files from the jdk
6704655: Test test/java/lang/reflect/Generics/Probe.java fails under OpenJDK
6705893: javax.script tests should not require a js engine on OpenJDK


Fixed in b11 - 
http://mail.openjdk.java.net/pipermail/jdk6-dev/2008-July/000067.html

6542088: JAX-WS server allows XXE attacks
6332953: JMX agent should bind to loopback address when starting the 
local connector server
6665028: native code of method j*.text.Bidi.nativeBidiChars is using the 
contents of a primitive array direct
6661918: Array reference changes behavior when compiled
6624717: Corrupted combo box, GTK L&F, Ubuntu 7.10
6621691: (dc) test/java/nio/channels/DatagramChannel/NotBound.java 
missing public modifier
6691328: DragSourceContext returns unexpected cursor
6685178: REGRESSION: NPE in ConnectorBootstrap when 
Agent.getManagementProperties() returns null.
6607339: IncrementalSAXSource_Filter still allows reading of local files
6601377: hotspot/src/share/vm/prims/jvmtiLib.xsl generates files with 
incorrect legal notices
6589868: transition to Mercurial: need to eliminate dependencies on SCCS 
keywords
6681796: hotspot build failure on gcc 4.2.x (ubuntu 8.04) w/ openjdk6
6695776: corba jscheme jar files in repository could be built from source
6695777: Queens.class should be built from source, not put in source repo
6565364: update legal notices in corba
6695765: Remove winver.exe completely from jdk sources
6705945: com.sun.tools.javac.zip files do not have valid copyright
6596323: (fc) ClosedByInterruptException not thrown by the interrupt 
method (lnx)
6710579: (ch) test/java/nio/channels/AsyncCloseAndInterrupt fails (lnx)
6623167: C2 crashed in StoreCMNode::Value
6497639: Profiling Swing application caused JVM crash
6599425: OopMapCache::lookup() can cause later crash or assert() failure
6659207: access violation in CompilerThread0
6614100: EXCEPTION_ACCESS_VIOLATION while running Eclipse with 1.6.0_05-ea
6608764: test/closed/java/awt/Focus/TemporaryLostComponentDeadlock fails
6620632: DTD event is missing entity and notation information
6601384: hotspot/src/share/vm/adlc/archDesc.cpp generates files with 
incorrect legal notices
6710791: Remove files or build them from source: maf-1_0.jar, jlfgr-1_0.jar
6713083: hotspot copy.cpp and vmStructs_parNew.hpp source files contains 
proprietary sun notice
6717575: Make sanity prints duplicated BUILD_JDK messages
6717694: Normalize src/share/classes/com/sun/media/sound


Fixed in b12 - 
http://mail.openjdk.java.net/pipermail/jdk6-dev/2008-September/000150.html

6590549: Cygwin build of OpenJDK has problems and not very well documented
6635663: make/tools/AutoMulti/{AutoMulti,TestALFGenerator}.java still 
generate files with wrong legal notices
6719182: update legal notice in 
src/share/classes/java/lang/instrument/package.html
6714428: 'os.name' system property shows wrong value on 64-bit Windows XP
6720240: IOB exception when getting font metrics of hershey font
6548261: Use of  SE in make/common/Defs-windows.gmk
6681798: (build) CharsetEncoder.java fails to compile in openjdk6 on 
ubuntu 8.04
6372405: Server thread hangs when fragments don't complete because of 
connection abort
5104239: Java: thread deadlock
6191561: JCK15: 
api/org_omg/PortableInterceptor/ClientRequestInfo/index.html#RIMethods 
sometime hang
6486322: org.omg.CORBA.ORB.init() thread safety issue
6465377: NullPointerException for RMI ORB in 1.5.0_08
6438259: Wrong repository ID generated by IDLJ
6509042: javac rejects class literals in enum constructors
6627362: javac generates code that uses array.clone, which is not 
available on JavaCard
6627364: javac needs Float and Double on the bootclasspath even when not 
directly used
6627366: javac needs Cloneable and Serializable on the classpath even 
when not directly used
6665223: Static import of inherited protected method causes compiler 
exception
6538484: JAF fails in Turkish locale
6699090: Avoid NPE if parse fails in isMimeTypeEqual, do a string 
comparison instead
6176978: current Javadoc's invocation and extension (Doclet) mechanisms 
are problematic
6681889: JSN security test headline/noWarningApp failed with NPE exception
6732815: CORBA_2_3 java sources not explicitly compiled
6734545: Corrections to missing explicit corba sources on javac compile 
lines
6573268: Four JCK-devtools-6a tests report OOM: Java Heap space since 
JDK7 b14
6720349: (ch) Channels tests depending on hosts inside Sun
6739302: Check that deserialization preserves EnumSet integrity
6730743: (tz) Support tzdata2008e
6741642: bad enum definition in ciTypeFlow.hpp
6717691: Update Gervill with post 1.0 fixes
6733501: Apply IcedTea little cms patches
6735154: Apply IcedTea Color.createContext patch
6738894: Merge jaxp fixes from 6 update train into OpenJDK 6
6740210: Update Gervill with more post 1.0 fixes
6748247: Further update Gervill with still more post 1.0 fixes