8u242 Rampdown: Bug Triage

Wed Dec 18 00:38:32 UTC 2019

Comments on four of these:

1. JDK-8041620: "Solaris Studio 12.4 C++ 5.13 change in behavior for
    placing friend declarations within surrounding scope".

Just deletes an unused C++ class. Can be deferred to 8u252.

2. JDK-8056313: "TEST_BUG: java/util/Timer/NameConstructors.java fails
    intermittently"

Test fix. Can be deferred to 8u252.

4. JDK-8143925: "enhancing CounterMode.crypt() for
    AESCrypt.implEncryptBlock()"

This is a performance enhancement, but the patch strictly speaking depends on previous patches such as the one for 8140779. The latter, however, is not tagged as backported by Oracle, so the Oracle 8143925 backport has been customized to avoid it. Imo too risky for 8u242.

7. JDK-8171974: "Fix for R10 Register clobbering with usage of
    ExternalAddress"

Appears to be a fix for 8150767, which is another performance enhancement that's not tagged as backported to 8u. 8150767 depends on 8143925 (#4 above).

Paul

On 12/16/19, 10:35 PM, "jdk8u-dev on behalf of Andrew John Hughes" <jdk8u-dev-bounces at openjdk.java.net on behalf of gnu.andrew at redhat.com> wrote:

    Hi all,

    We have reached the point of rampdown for 8u242 where work will now be
    deferred to 8u252, unless a critical request to include it in 8u242 is
    approved (see [0]).

    I've been going through the list of bugs which are marked as fixed in
    Oracle's proprietary 8u241/2 [1] to see what is still missing in OpenJDK 8u:

    1. JDK-8041620: "Solaris Studio 12.4 C++ 5.13 change in behavior for
    placing friend declarations within surrounding scope".

    No sign of a backport for 8u.

    2. JDK-8056313: "TEST_BUG: java/util/Timer/NameConstructors.java fails
    intermittently"

    No sign of a backport to 8u.

    3. JDK-8080462: "Update SunPKCS11 provider with PKCS11 v2.40 support"

    Still under review; postponed to 8u252.

    4. JDK-8143925: "enhancing CounterMode.crypt() for
    AESCrypt.implEncryptBlock()"

    No sign of a backport to 8u.

    5. JDK-8146581: "Minor corrections to the patch submitted for earlier
    bug id - 8143925"

    No sign of a backport to 8u and depends on #5.

    6. JDK-8148188: "Enhance the security libraries to record events of
    interest"

    Depends on JFR so one for that branch for now.

    7. JDK-8171974: "Fix for R10 Register clobbering with usage of
    ExternalAddress"

    No sign of a backport to 8u.

    8. JDK-8177334: "Update xmldsig implementation to Apache Santuario 2.1.1"

    Major backport already defered from 8u232. Postponed to 8u252.

    9. JDK-8200400: "Allow Sasl mechanisms to be restricted"

    Waiting on CSR https://bugs.openjdk.java.net/browse/JDK-8230491

    10. JDK-8201627: "Kerberos sequence number issues"

    Still under review; needs backports of JDK-8186884 & JDK-8154231.

    11. JDK-8205507: "jdk/javax/xml/crypto/dsig/GenerationTests.java timed out"

    Depends on 8177334 (#9), so also deferred to 8u252.

    12. JDK-8217581: "JDK 8 javadoc man page does not list correct values
    for -source"

    No sign of a backport to 8u.

    13. JDK-8217878: "ENVELOPING XML signature no longer works"

    Depends on 8177334 (#9), so also deferred to 8u252.

    14. JDK-8218605: "Startup Splash Screen of SwingSet2 flashes in smaller
    coordinates before appearing in the final size"

    No progress since 8u232.

    15. JDK-8218629: "XML Digital Signature throws NAMESPACE_ERR exception
    on OpenJDK 11, works 8/9/10"

    Depends on 8177334 (#8), so also deferred to 8u252.

    16. JDK-8219013: "Update Apache Santuario (XML Signature) to version 2.1.3"

    Depends on 8177334 (#8), so also deferred to 8u252.

    17. JDK-8225695: "32-bit build failures after JDK-8080462 (Update
    SunPKCS11 provider with PKCS11 v2.40 support)"

    Depends on 8080462 (#3), so also deferred to 8u252.

    18. JDK-8228835: "Memory leak in PKCS11 provider when using AES GCM"

    Caused by 8080462 (#3), so also deferred to 8u252.

    19. JDK-8229243: "SunPKCS11-Solaris provider tests failing on Solaris 11.4"

    Caused by 8080462 (#3), so also deferred to 8u252.

    20. JDK-8229767: "Typo in java.security: Sasl.createClient and
    Sasl.createServer"

    Depends on 8200400 (#9), so deferred to 8u252.

    21. JDK-8229868: "Update Apache Santuario TPRM version"

    Can be combined with 8219013 (#16), so deferred to 8u252.

    22. JDK-8230303: "JDB hangs when running monitor command"

    No sign of a backport to 8u.

    23. JDK-8230751: "The underline of the text doesn't display unless
    resizing the window with the option "-server -d64 -Xmixed
    -Dswing.defaultlaf=com.sun.java.swing.plaf.gtk.GTKLookAndFeel".

    No patch, no sign of a fix for 8u.

    24. JDK-8210776: "Upgrade X Window System 6.8.2 to the latest XWD 1.0.7"

    Patch not posted until 2019-12-16, deferred to 8u252.

    25. JDK-8230782: "Robot.createScreenCapture() fails if “awt.robot.gtk”
    is set to false"

    Depends on 8210776 (#24)

    26. JDK-8231254: "(fs) Add test for macOS Catalina changes to protect
    system software"

    No sign of a backport to 8u.

    27. JDK-8232019: "Add LuxTrust certificate updates to the existing root
    program"

    No sign of a backport to 8u.

    28. JDK-8232178: "MacVolumesTest failed after upgrade to MacOS Catalina"

    No sign of a backport to 8u.

    29. JDK-8233223: "Add Amazon Root CA certificates"

    No sign of a backport to 8u.

    Although this appears to be a long list, a number of them are related,
    particularly #8 and friends which have already been deferred from 8u232.
    Hopefully, there will be some progress on that for 8u252. The highest
    numbered bugs also seem to have been added to the list very late in the
    release cycle.

    Thanks to everyone who has submitted patches and/or reviews during the
    8u242 development cycle. Onwards to 8u252!

    [0] https://wiki.openjdk.java.net/display/jdk8u/Main
    [1] https://bugs.openjdk.java.net/issues/?filter=37085

    Thanks,
    -- 
    Andrew :)

    Senior Free Java Software Engineer
    Red Hat, Inc. (http://www.redhat.com)

    PGP Key: ed25519/0xCFDA0F9B35964222 (hkp://keys.gnupg.net)
    Fingerprint = 5132 579D D154 0ED2 3E04  C5A0 CFDA 0F9B 3596 4222
    https://keybase.io/gnu_andrew