Unable to derive module descriptor for gradle-api-5 .6.2.jar — Provider class moduleName=model-core not in module

[Plugins]

Hi Alan,

Thanks for replying. 

Myself and other developers are encountering and reporting other
Gradle-related JPMS-development blocking issues similar to the topic of
this thread [4].

Comments like these from Gradle core devs...


>> „...There's no short-term plan to work on jigsaw support, so please don't hold your breath...“ [5]
    
>> „...Your best bet is to look for a community plugin that adds support for Java modules. We don’t have anything built-in yet...“ [6]


...give the impression that the organization is not all that
enthusiastic about making JPMS development easy when building with
Gradle.


> „...Gradle seems to have re-packaged the BC provider into the org.gradle.internal.impldep.org.bouncycastle name space but missed the services configuration file. There could issues here on multiple levels that are nothing to do with modules...“


With all the super-advanced, rock star devs at Gradle, it's hard for me
to believe that nobody on that team considered at least some of those
potential issues. Things like that bring out the conspiracy theorist in
me. Innocent whoopsies like misconfiguring the security provider come
off as ways to passively undermine JPMS adoption. That's where I'm
coming from with „Anti-JPMS“.

Whatever Gradle Inc's actual strategic intentions are, because their
build tool is so popular, their apparent lackadaisical, do-nothing
strategy on JPMS has the _practical_ effect of blocking wider JPMS
adoption.

And, of course, Gradle's dedicated Super Fans will take the same
anti-JPMS position. For a lot of those fans, their reasons might not be
based on the practical nor the technical merits of JPMS. But for no
reason other than: „just because Gradle says so“.


----
[4] http://bit.ly/ArgsHmmm 
[5] http://bit.ly/OehmeBreath
[6] http://bit.ly/bigguYet




-------- Original Message --------
Subject: RE: Unable to derive module descriptor for gradle-api-5.6.2.jar

— Provider class moduleName=model-core not in module
From: Alan Bateman <Alan.Bateman at oracle.com>
Date: Fri, October 11, 2019 16:45 pm
To: Plugins <plugins at lingocoder.com>, jigsaw-dev at openjdk.java.net

On 11/10/2019 23:41, Plugins wrote:
> While trying to find a solution to what I lovingly call Gradle's
> „Anti-JPMS“ issue [1],
Just on this one, the analysis in the issue seems to be correct. Gradle 
seems to have re-packaged the BC provider into the 
org.gradle.internal.impldep.org.bouncycastle name space but missed the 
services configuration file. There could issues here on multiple levels 
that are nothing to do with modules.

-Alan