From glyn.normington at springsource.com Wed Jan 9 13:36:28 2008 From: glyn.normington at springsource.com (Glyn Normington) Date: Wed, 9 Jan 2008 16:36:28 -0500 Subject: [modules-discuss] How to raise sunbugs? Message-ID: <8581675F-79DE-4D5B-8E37-15275841CFE9@springsource.com> What value of the product/category field should be used when raising a bug against the modules project? Thanks, Glyn From Andreas.Sterbenz at Sun.COM Thu Jan 10 09:09:10 2008 From: Andreas.Sterbenz at Sun.COM (Andreas Sterbenz) Date: Thu, 10 Jan 2008 09:09:10 -0800 Subject: [modules-discuss] How to raise sunbugs? In-Reply-To: <8581675F-79DE-4D5B-8E37-15275841CFE9@springsource.com> References: <8581675F-79DE-4D5B-8E37-15275841CFE9@springsource.com> Message-ID: <47865136.3020204@sun.com> Glyn Normington wrote: > What value of the product/category field should be used when raising > a bug against the modules project? For now it would be easiest to report any bugs or other implementation issues here. The bugs.sun.com mechanism was designed for released products and does not work well for OpenJDK. Eventually we will have a bug database that all community members have full access to, but we are not there yet. Is there something you would like to report? For spec bugs and other issues with the JSR 277 and JSR 294 specs, please continue to use the the JCP feedback channels such as jsr-277-comments at jcp.org and jsr-294-comments at jcp.org . Andreas. From glyn.normington at springsource.com Thu Jan 10 11:41:23 2008 From: glyn.normington at springsource.com (Glyn Normington) Date: Thu, 10 Jan 2008 14:41:23 -0500 Subject: [modules-discuss] How to raise sunbugs? In-Reply-To: <47865136.3020204@sun.com> References: <8581675F-79DE-4D5B-8E37-15275841CFE9@springsource.com> <47865136.3020204@sun.com> Message-ID: On Jan 10, 2008, at 12:09 PM, Andreas Sterbenz wrote: > Glyn Normington wrote: >> What value of the product/category field should be used when >> raising a bug against the modules project? > > For now it would be easiest to report any bugs or other > implementation issues here. The bugs.sun.com mechanism was designed > for released products and does not work well for OpenJDK. > Eventually we will have a bug database that all community members > have full access to, but we are not there yet. > > Is there something you would like to report? > > For spec bugs and other issues with the JSR 277 and JSR 294 specs, > please continue to use the the JCP feedback channels such as > jsr-277-comments at jcp.org and jsr-294-comments at jcp.org . > > Andreas. > Hi Andreas I can no longer commit time to tracking the JSR 277 mailing list so I'd like to formally log the requirement for JSR 277 to interoperate with JSR 291 as an enhancement request. There are a number of benefits of using a bug to do this: 1. I can subscribe to the bug and know I will be notified if and when it is fixed (I will very likely remain interested in the outcome of the bug but not in the detailed process in deriving a solution) 2. a bug will not float off into obscurity unlike archived mailing list threads 3. a bug is a good way of tracking the status of "to do" items for any project. This mailing list and the JCP feedback aliases do not provide these benefits plus I've already mentioned the interop. issue many times on the JSR 277 mailing list and there is still no formal way of tracking the progress of the item. Glyn From hal.hildebrand at oracle.com Thu Jan 10 14:27:21 2008 From: hal.hildebrand at oracle.com (Hal Hildebrand) Date: Thu, 10 Jan 2008 17:27:21 -0500 Subject: [modules-discuss] How to raise sunbugs? In-Reply-To: References: <8581675F-79DE-4D5B-8E37-15275841CFE9@springsource.com> <47865136.3020204@sun.com> Message-ID: <6C85F2AA-A0FB-47C1-ADF1-3692E91204E4@oracle.com> +1 On Jan 10, 2008, at 2:41 PM, Glyn Normington wrote: > On Jan 10, 2008, at 12:09 PM, Andreas Sterbenz wrote: > >> Glyn Normington wrote: >>> What value of the product/category field should be used when >>> raising a bug against the modules project? >> >> For now it would be easiest to report any bugs or other >> implementation issues here. The bugs.sun.com mechanism was designed >> for released products and does not work well for OpenJDK. >> Eventually we will have a bug database that all community members >> have full access to, but we are not there yet. >> >> Is there something you would like to report? >> >> For spec bugs and other issues with the JSR 277 and JSR 294 specs, >> please continue to use the the JCP feedback channels such as >> jsr-277-comments at jcp.org and jsr-294-comments at jcp.org . >> >> Andreas. >> > > Hi Andreas > > I can no longer commit time to tracking the JSR 277 mailing list so > I'd like to formally log the requirement for JSR 277 to interoperate > with JSR 291 as an enhancement request. There are a number of > benefits of using a bug to do this: > > 1. I can subscribe to the bug and know I will be notified if and when > it is fixed (I will very likely remain interested in the outcome of > the bug but not in the detailed process in deriving a solution) > 2. a bug will not float off into obscurity unlike archived mailing > list threads > 3. a bug is a good way of tracking the status of "to do" items for > any project. > > This mailing list and the JCP feedback aliases do not provide these > benefits plus I've already mentioned the interop. issue many times on > the JSR 277 mailing list and there is still no formal way of tracking > the progress of the item. > > Glyn > _______________________________________________ > modules-discuss mailing list > modules-discuss at openjdk.java.net > http://mail.openjdk.java.net/mailman/listinfo/modules-discuss From Andreas.Sterbenz at Sun.COM Mon Jan 14 18:53:21 2008 From: Andreas.Sterbenz at Sun.COM (Andreas Sterbenz) Date: Mon, 14 Jan 2008 18:53:21 -0800 Subject: [modules-discuss] How to raise sunbugs? In-Reply-To: References: <8581675F-79DE-4D5B-8E37-15275841CFE9@springsource.com> <47865136.3020204@sun.com> Message-ID: <478C2021.4020203@sun.com> Glyn Normington wrote: > > I can no longer commit time to tracking the JSR 277 mailing list so > I'd like to formally log the requirement for JSR 277 to interoperate > with JSR 291 as an enhancement request. I filed 6650394 to track this. It should become visible at http://bugs.sun.com/view_bug.do?bug_id=6650394 within a day or two. You can set a watch there which should ensure that you get an email whenever there is an update. Andreas.