[External] : Re: Eclipse and Gradle in OpenJFX

[Nir Lisker]

Sorry for the late reply, I have a lot on my plate.

why we need to jump through the hoops with the initial import (reverting
> the changes etc.) even if it described and


We don't *need* to, but using Gradle within Eclipse makes it easier to work
with, at least for some people. The Gradle integration for Eclipse removes
the need for a separate command line. You can run all the Gradle commands
from within Eclipse.

what 'eclipse' task you are referring to?  There is no 'eclipse' task in
> build.gradle as far as I can see (see below)


I have 2 tasks from the 'eclipse' plugin (
https://docs.gradle.org/current/userguide/eclipse_plugin.html). It looks
like that plugin is applied automatically in my workspace for all Gradle
projects. That plugin adds a task called 'eclipse' that creates the Eclipse
project and classpath files from the gradle build file. When I use it in my
projects, it works very well and I don't need to add special --add-modules
arguments, for example. I just tried it with OpenJFX and it works very
badly. I played with the huge gradle build file to see where the problems
come from. In summary, that file was written with Gradle 2 it seems and
uses features that aren't needed anymore and it trips the plugin up.


What is the value of keeping these steps and complicating the process (with
> Eclipse)?


Working directly from the IDE without needing a command line. However, I
suppose that anyone who wants to use Gradle from Eclipse can convert the
projects to Gradle projects. Then again, anyone who doesn't want that can
disable the Gradle nature of the projects. Both of these are a one-time
action.

I will continue the technical discussion on
https://github.com/openjdk/jfx/pull/1491.

On Thu, Jun 20, 2024 at 6:16 PM Andy Goryachev <andy.goryachev at oracle.com>
wrote:

> Nir:
>
>
>
> I don't understand two things:
>
>
>
>    1. why we need to jump through the hoops with the initial import
>    (reverting the changes etc.) even if it described and
>    2. what 'eclipse' task you are referring to?  There is no 'eclipse'
>    task in build.gradle as far as I can see (see below)
>
>
>
> What is the value of keeping these steps and complicating the process
> (with Eclipse)?
>
>
>
> -andy
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
> $ gradle -q :tasks --all
>
> Defining Closed Properties
>
> [...snip...]
>
>
>
> *------------------------------------------------------------*
>
> *Tasks runnable from root project 'rt'*
>
> *------------------------------------------------------------*
>
>
>
> Default tasks: sdk
>
>
>
> *Basic tasks*
>
> *-----------*
>
> appsMac - Runs the apps creation tasks
>
> buildModuleBaseMac - creates javafx.base property files
>
> buildModuleGraphicsMac - copies javafx.graphics native libraries
>
> buildModuleLibsMac
>
> buildModuleMediaMac - copies javafx.media native libraries
>
> buildModuleSWTMac - copies SWT JAR
>
> buildModuleWebMac - copies javafx.web native libraries
>
> clean - Deletes the build directory and the build directory of all sub
> projects
>
> cleanAll - Scrubs the repo of build artifacts
>
> findbugsMac - Runs the findbugs creation tasks
>
> javadoc - Generates the JavaDoc for all the public API
>
> javafxSwtMac - Creates the javafx-swt.jar for the mac target
>
> base:jmodCopyLibMac - copied Windows DLLs into javafx subdir for jmods
>
> controls:jmodCopyLibMac - copied Windows DLLs into javafx subdir for jmods
>
> fxml:jmodCopyLibMac - copied Windows DLLs into javafx subdir for jmods
>
> graphics:jmodCopyLibMac - copied Windows DLLs into javafx subdir for jmods
>
> media:jmodCopyLibMac - copied Windows DLLs into javafx subdir for jmods
>
> swing:jmodCopyLibMac - copied Windows DLLs into javafx subdir for jmods
>
> web:jmodCopyLibMac - copied Windows DLLs into javafx subdir for jmods
>
> publicExportsMac - Creates the public export bundles
>
> publicExportsStandaloneMac - Creates the disk layout for sdk, jmods, and
> docs
>
> sdkArtifactsMac - Copies bundled and standalone sdk dirs into artifacts
> for mac
>
> sdkMac
>
> targzJmodsMac - Creates the public jmods tar.gz bundle
>
> targzSdkMac - Creates the public sdk tar.gz bundle
>
> zipsMac - Creates the public zip bundles
>
> zipsStandaloneMac - Creates the public zip bundles
>
>
>
> *Build tasks*
>
> *-----------*
>
> base:assemble - Assembles the outputs of this project.
>
> closedTests:assemble - Assembles the outputs of this project.
>
> controls:assemble - Assembles the outputs of this project.
>
> fxml:assemble - Assembles the outputs of this project.
>
> graphics:assemble - Assembles the outputs of this project.
>
> media:assemble - Assembles the outputs of this project.
>
> swing:assemble - Assembles the outputs of this project.
>
> swt:assemble - Assembles the outputs of this project.
>
> systemTests:assemble - Assembles the outputs of this project.
>
> web:assemble - Assembles the outputs of this project.
>
> base:build - Assembles and tests this project.
>
> closedTests:build - Assembles and tests this project.
>
> controls:build - Assembles and tests this project.
>
> fxml:build - Assembles and tests this project.
>
> graphics:build - Assembles and tests this project.
>
> media:build - Assembles and tests this project.
>
> swing:build - Assembles and tests this project.
>
> swt:build - Assembles and tests this project.
>
> systemTests:build - Assembles and tests this project.
>
> web:build - Assembles and tests this project.
>
> base:buildDependents - Assembles and tests this project and all projects
> that depend on it.
>
> closedTests:buildDependents - Assembles and tests this project and all
> projects that depend on it.
>
> controls:buildDependents - Assembles and tests this project and all
> projects that depend on it.
>
> fxml:buildDependents - Assembles and tests this project and all projects
> that depend on it.
>
> graphics:buildDependents - Assembles and tests this project and all
> projects that depend on it.
>
> media:buildDependents - Assembles and tests this project and all projects
> that depend on it.
>
> swing:buildDependents - Assembles and tests this project and all projects
> that depend on it.
>
> swt:buildDependents - Assembles and tests this project and all projects
> that depend on it.
>
> systemTests:buildDependents - Assembles and tests this project and all
> projects that depend on it.
>
> web:buildDependents - Assembles and tests this project and all projects
> that depend on it.
>
> base:buildModuleMac
>
> controls:buildModuleMac
>
> fxml:buildModuleMac
>
> graphics:buildModuleMac
>
> media:buildModuleMac
>
> swing:buildModuleMac
>
> web:buildModuleMac
>
> buildModulesMac
>
> buildModuleZipMac
>
> base:buildNeeded - Assembles and tests this project and all projects it
> depends on.
>
> closedTests:buildNeeded - Assembles and tests this project and all
> projects it depends on.
>
> controls:buildNeeded - Assembles and tests this project and all projects
> it depends on.
>
> fxml:buildNeeded - Assembles and tests this project and all projects it
> depends on.
>
> graphics:buildNeeded - Assembles and tests this project and all projects
> it depends on.
>
> media:buildNeeded - Assembles and tests this project and all projects it
> depends on.
>
> swing:buildNeeded - Assembles and tests this project and all projects it
> depends on.
>
> swt:buildNeeded - Assembles and tests this project and all projects it
> depends on.
>
> systemTests:buildNeeded - Assembles and tests this project and all
> projects it depends on.
>
> web:buildNeeded - Assembles and tests this project and all projects it
> depends on.
>
> buildRunArgsMac
>
> graphics:ccMacFont - Compiles native sources for font for mac
>
> graphics:ccMacGlass - Compiles native sources for glass for mac
>
> graphics:ccMacIio - Compiles native sources for iio for mac
>
> graphics:ccMacPrism - Compiles native sources for prism for mac
>
> graphics:ccMacPrismES2 - Compiles native sources for prismES2 for mac
>
> graphics:ccMacPrismSW - Compiles native sources for prismSW for mac
>
> base:classes - Assembles main classes.
>
> closedTests:classes - Assembles main classes.
>
> controls:classes - Assembles main classes.
>
> fxml:classes - Assembles main classes.
>
> graphics:classes - Assembles main classes.
>
> media:classes - Assembles main classes.
>
> swing:classes - Assembles main classes.
>
> swt:classes - Assembles main classes.
>
> systemTests:classes - Assembles main classes.
>
> web:classes - Assembles main classes.
>
> base:clean - Deletes the build directory.
>
> closedTests:clean - Deletes the build directory.
>
> controls:clean - Deletes the build directory.
>
> fxml:clean - Deletes the build directory.
>
> graphics:clean - Deletes the build directory.
>
> media:clean - Deletes the build directory.
>
> swing:clean - Deletes the build directory.
>
> swt:clean - Deletes the build directory.
>
> systemTests:clean - Deletes the build directory.
>
> web:clean - Deletes the build directory.
>
> graphics:cleanNative - Clean all native libraries and objects for Graphics
>
> graphics:cleanNativeDecora - Clean native objects for Decora
>
> graphics:cleanNativeFont - Clean native objects for font
>
> graphics:cleanNativeGlass - Clean native objects for glass
>
> graphics:cleanNativeIio - Clean native objects for iio
>
> graphics:cleanNativePrism - Clean native objects for prism
>
> graphics:cleanNativePrismES2 - Clean native objects for prismES2
>
> graphics:cleanNativePrismSW - Clean native objects for prismSW
>
> createMSPfile
>
> base:jar - Assembles a jar archive containing the classes of the 'main'
> feature.
>
> closedTests:jar - Assembles a jar archive containing the classes of the
> 'main' feature.
>
> controls:jar - Assembles a jar archive containing the classes of the
> 'main' feature.
>
> fxml:jar - Assembles a jar archive containing the classes of the 'main'
> feature.
>
> graphics:jar - Assembles a jar archive containing the classes of the
> 'main' feature.
>
> media:jar - Assembles a jar archive containing the classes of the 'main'
> feature.
>
> swing:jar - Assembles a jar archive containing the classes of the 'main'
> feature.
>
> swt:jar - Assembles a jar archive containing the classes of the 'main'
> feature.
>
> systemTests:jar - Assembles a jar archive containing the classes of the
> 'main' feature.
>
> web:jar - Assembles a jar archive containing the classes of the 'main'
> feature.
>
> base:jmodMac
>
> controls:jmodMac
>
> fxml:jmodMac
>
> graphics:jmodMac
>
> media:jmodMac
>
> swing:jmodMac
>
> web:jmodMac
>
> graphics:jslcClasses - Assembles jslc classes.
>
> graphics:linkMacFont - Creates native dynamic library for font for mac
>
> graphics:linkMacGlass - Creates native dynamic library for glass for mac
>
> graphics:linkMacIio - Creates native dynamic library for iio for mac
>
> graphics:linkMacPrism - Creates native dynamic library for prism for mac
>
> graphics:linkMacPrismES2 - Creates native dynamic library for prismES2
> for mac
>
> graphics:linkMacPrismSW - Creates native dynamic library for prismSW for
> mac
>
> graphics:native - Compiles and Builds all native libraries for Graphics
>
> graphics:nativeDecora - Generates JNI headers, compiles, and builds
> native dynamic library for Decora
>
> graphics:nativeFont - Generates JNI headers, compiles, and builds native
> dynamic library for font for all compile targets
>
> graphics:nativeGlass - Generates JNI headers, compiles, and builds native
> dynamic library for glass for all compile targets
>
> graphics:nativeIio - Generates JNI headers, compiles, and builds native
> dynamic library for iio for all compile targets
>
> graphics:nativePrism - Generates JNI headers, compiles, and builds native
> dynamic library for prism for all compile targets
>
> graphics:nativePrismES2 - Generates JNI headers, compiles, and builds
> native dynamic library for prismES2 for all compile targets
>
> graphics:nativePrismSW - Generates JNI headers, compiles, and builds
> native dynamic library for prismSW for all compile targets
>
> graphics:shadersClasses - Assembles shaders classes.
>
> base:shimsClasses - Assembles shims classes.
>
> controls:shimsClasses - Assembles shims classes.
>
> fxml:shimsClasses - Assembles shims classes.
>
> graphics:shimsClasses - Assembles shims classes.
>
> swing:shimsClasses - Assembles shims classes.
>
> web:shimsClasses - Assembles shims classes.
>
> graphics:stubClasses - Assembles stub classes.
>
> systemTests:testapp1Classes - Assembles testapp1 classes.
>
> systemTests:testapp2Classes - Assembles testapp2 classes.
>
> systemTests:testapp3Classes - Assembles testapp3 classes.
>
> systemTests:testapp4Classes - Assembles testapp4 classes.
>
> systemTests:testapp5Classes - Assembles testapp5 classes.
>
> systemTests:testapp6Classes - Assembles testapp6 classes.
>
> systemTests:testapp7Classes - Assembles testapp7 classes.
>
> base:testClasses - Assembles test classes.
>
> closedTests:testClasses - Assembles test classes.
>
> controls:testClasses - Assembles test classes.
>
> fxml:testClasses - Assembles test classes.
>
> graphics:testClasses - Assembles test classes.
>
> media:testClasses - Assembles test classes.
>
> swing:testClasses - Assembles test classes.
>
> swt:testClasses - Assembles test classes.
>
> systemTests:testClasses - Assembles test classes.
>
> web:testClasses - Assembles test classes.
>
> systemTests:testscriptapp1Classes - Assembles testscriptapp1 classes.
>
> systemTests:testscriptapp2Classes - Assembles testscriptapp2 classes.
>
> media:toolsClasses - Assembles tools classes.
>
>
>
> *Build Setup tasks*
>
> *-----------------*
>
> init - Initializes a new Gradle build.
>
> wrapper - Generates Gradle wrapper files.
>
>
>
> *Documentation tasks*
>
> *-------------------*
>
> base:javadoc - Generates Javadoc API documentation for the 'main' feature.
>
> closedTests:javadoc - Generates Javadoc API documentation for the 'main'
> feature.
>
> controls:javadoc - Generates Javadoc API documentation for the 'main'
> feature.
>
> fxml:javadoc - Generates Javadoc API documentation for the 'main' feature.
>
> graphics:javadoc - Generates Javadoc API documentation for the 'main'
> feature.
>
> media:javadoc - Generates Javadoc API documentation for the 'main'
> feature.
>
> swing:javadoc - Generates Javadoc API documentation for the 'main'
> feature.
>
> swt:javadoc - Generates Javadoc API documentation for the 'main' feature.
>
> systemTests:javadoc - Generates Javadoc API documentation for the 'main'
> feature.
>
> web:javadoc - Generates Javadoc API documentation for the 'main' feature.
>
>
>
> *Help tasks*
>
> *----------*
>
> buildEnvironment - Displays all buildscript dependencies declared in root
> project 'rt'.
>
> apps:buildEnvironment - Displays all buildscript dependencies declared in
> project ':apps'.
>
> base:buildEnvironment - Displays all buildscript dependencies declared in
> project ':base'.
>
> closedTests:buildEnvironment - Displays all buildscript dependencies
> declared in project ':closedTests'.
>
> controls:buildEnvironment - Displays all buildscript dependencies
> declared in project ':controls'.
>
> fxml:buildEnvironment - Displays all buildscript dependencies declared in
> project ':fxml'.
>
> graphics:buildEnvironment - Displays all buildscript dependencies
> declared in project ':graphics'.
>
> media:buildEnvironment - Displays all buildscript dependencies declared
> in project ':media'.
>
> swing:buildEnvironment - Displays all buildscript dependencies declared
> in project ':swing'.
>
> swt:buildEnvironment - Displays all buildscript dependencies declared in
> project ':swt'.
>
> systemTests:buildEnvironment - Displays all buildscript dependencies
> declared in project ':systemTests'.
>
> web:buildEnvironment - Displays all buildscript dependencies declared in
> project ':web'.
>
> dependencies - Displays all dependencies declared in root project 'rt'.
>
> apps:dependencies - Displays all dependencies declared in project ':apps'.
>
> base:dependencies - Displays all dependencies declared in project ':base'.
>
> closedTests:dependencies - Displays all dependencies declared in project
> ':closedTests'.
>
> controls:dependencies - Displays all dependencies declared in project
> ':controls'.
>
> fxml:dependencies - Displays all dependencies declared in project ':fxml'.
>
> graphics:dependencies - Displays all dependencies declared in project
> ':graphics'.
>
> media:dependencies - Displays all dependencies declared in project
> ':media'.
>
> swing:dependencies - Displays all dependencies declared in project
> ':swing'.
>
> swt:dependencies - Displays all dependencies declared in project ':swt'.
>
> systemTests:dependencies - Displays all dependencies declared in project
> ':systemTests'.
>
> web:dependencies - Displays all dependencies declared in project ':web'.
>
> dependencyInsight - Displays the insight into a specific dependency in
> root project 'rt'.
>
> apps:dependencyInsight - Displays the insight into a specific dependency
> in project ':apps'.
>
> base:dependencyInsight - Displays the insight into a specific dependency
> in project ':base'.
>
> closedTests:dependencyInsight - Displays the insight into a specific
> dependency in project ':closedTests'.
>
> controls:dependencyInsight - Displays the insight into a specific
> dependency in project ':controls'.
>
> fxml:dependencyInsight - Displays the insight into a specific dependency
> in project ':fxml'.
>
> graphics:dependencyInsight - Displays the insight into a specific
> dependency in project ':graphics'.
>
> media:dependencyInsight - Displays the insight into a specific dependency
> in project ':media'.
>
> swing:dependencyInsight - Displays the insight into a specific dependency
> in project ':swing'.
>
> swt:dependencyInsight - Displays the insight into a specific dependency
> in project ':swt'.
>
> systemTests:dependencyInsight - Displays the insight into a specific
> dependency in project ':systemTests'.
>
> web:dependencyInsight - Displays the insight into a specific dependency
> in project ':web'.
>
> help - Displays a help message.
>
> apps:help - Displays a help message.
>
> base:help - Displays a help message.
>
> closedTests:help - Displays a help message.
>
> controls:help - Displays a help message.
>
> fxml:help - Displays a help message.
>
> graphics:help - Displays a help message.
>
> media:help - Displays a help message.
>
> swing:help - Displays a help message.
>
> swt:help - Displays a help message.
>
> systemTests:help - Displays a help message.
>
> web:help - Displays a help message.
>
> javaToolchains - Displays the detected java toolchains.
>
> apps:javaToolchains - Displays the detected java toolchains.
>
> base:javaToolchains - Displays the detected java toolchains.
>
> closedTests:javaToolchains - Displays the detected java toolchains.
>
> controls:javaToolchains - Displays the detected java toolchains.
>
> fxml:javaToolchains - Displays the detected java toolchains.
>
> graphics:javaToolchains - Displays the detected java toolchains.
>
> media:javaToolchains - Displays the detected java toolchains.
>
> swing:javaToolchains - Displays the detected java toolchains.
>
> swt:javaToolchains - Displays the detected java toolchains.
>
> systemTests:javaToolchains - Displays the detected java toolchains.
>
> web:javaToolchains - Displays the detected java toolchains.
>
> outgoingVariants - Displays the outgoing variants of root project 'rt'.
>
> apps:outgoingVariants - Displays the outgoing variants of project ':apps'.
>
> base:outgoingVariants - Displays the outgoing variants of project ':base'.
>
> closedTests:outgoingVariants - Displays the outgoing variants of project
> ':closedTests'.
>
> controls:outgoingVariants - Displays the outgoing variants of project
> ':controls'.
>
> fxml:outgoingVariants - Displays the outgoing variants of project ':fxml'.
>
> graphics:outgoingVariants - Displays the outgoing variants of project
> ':graphics'.
>
> media:outgoingVariants - Displays the outgoing variants of project
> ':media'.
>
> swing:outgoingVariants - Displays the outgoing variants of project
> ':swing'.
>
> swt:outgoingVariants - Displays the outgoing variants of project ':swt'.
>
> systemTests:outgoingVariants - Displays the outgoing variants of project
> ':systemTests'.
>
> web:outgoingVariants - Displays the outgoing variants of project ':web'.
>
> projects - Displays the sub-projects of root project 'rt'.
>
> apps:projects - Displays the sub-projects of project ':apps'.
>
> base:projects - Displays the sub-projects of project ':base'.
>
> closedTests:projects - Displays the sub-projects of project
> ':closedTests'.
>
> controls:projects - Displays the sub-projects of project ':controls'.
>
> fxml:projects - Displays the sub-projects of project ':fxml'.
>
> graphics:projects - Displays the sub-projects of project ':graphics'.
>
> media:projects - Displays the sub-projects of project ':media'.
>
> swing:projects - Displays the sub-projects of project ':swing'.
>
> swt:projects - Displays the sub-projects of project ':swt'.
>
> systemTests:projects - Displays the sub-projects of project
> ':systemTests'.
>
> web:projects - Displays the sub-projects of project ':web'.
>
> properties - Displays the properties of root project 'rt'.
>
> apps:properties - Displays the properties of project ':apps'.
>
> base:properties - Displays the properties of project ':base'.
>
> closedTests:properties - Displays the properties of project
> ':closedTests'.
>
> controls:properties - Displays the properties of project ':controls'.
>
> fxml:properties - Displays the properties of project ':fxml'.
>
> graphics:properties - Displays the properties of project ':graphics'.
>
> media:properties - Displays the properties of project ':media'.
>
> swing:properties - Displays the properties of project ':swing'.
>
> swt:properties - Displays the properties of project ':swt'.
>
> systemTests:properties - Displays the properties of project
> ':systemTests'.
>
> web:properties - Displays the properties of project ':web'.
>
> resolvableConfigurations - Displays the configurations that can be
> resolved in root project 'rt'.
>
> apps:resolvableConfigurations - Displays the configurations that can be
> resolved in project ':apps'.
>
> base:resolvableConfigurations - Displays the configurations that can be
> resolved in project ':base'.
>
> closedTests:resolvableConfigurations - Displays the configurations that
> can be resolved in project ':closedTests'.
>
> controls:resolvableConfigurations - Displays the configurations that can
> be resolved in project ':controls'.
>
> fxml:resolvableConfigurations - Displays the configurations that can be
> resolved in project ':fxml'.
>
> graphics:resolvableConfigurations - Displays the configurations that can
> be resolved in project ':graphics'.
>
> media:resolvableConfigurations - Displays the configurations that can be
> resolved in project ':media'.
>
> swing:resolvableConfigurations - Displays the configurations that can be
> resolved in project ':swing'.
>
> swt:resolvableConfigurations - Displays the configurations that can be
> resolved in project ':swt'.
>
> systemTests:resolvableConfigurations - Displays the configurations that
> can be resolved in project ':systemTests'.
>
> web:resolvableConfigurations - Displays the configurations that can be
> resolved in project ':web'.
>
> tasks - Displays the tasks runnable from root project 'rt' (some of the
> displayed tasks may belong to subprojects).
>
> apps:tasks - Displays the tasks runnable from project ':apps'.
>
> base:tasks - Displays the tasks runnable from project ':base'.
>
> closedTests:tasks - Displays the tasks runnable from project
> ':closedTests'.
>
> controls:tasks - Displays the tasks runnable from project ':controls'.
>
> fxml:tasks - Displays the tasks runnable from project ':fxml'.
>
> graphics:tasks - Displays the tasks runnable from project ':graphics'.
>
> media:tasks - Displays the tasks runnable from project ':media'.
>
> swing:tasks - Displays the tasks runnable from project ':swing'.
>
> swt:tasks - Displays the tasks runnable from project ':swt'.
>
> systemTests:tasks - Displays the tasks runnable from project
> ':systemTests'.
>
> web:tasks - Displays the tasks runnable from project ':web'.
>
>
>
> *Verification tasks*
>
> *------------------*
>
> base:check - Runs all checks.
>
> closedTests:check - Runs all checks.
>
> controls:check - Runs all checks.
>
> fxml:check - Runs all checks.
>
> graphics:check - Runs all checks.
>
> media:check - Runs all checks.
>
> swing:check - Runs all checks.
>
> swt:check - Runs all checks.
>
> systemTests:check - Runs all checks.
>
> web:check - Runs all checks.
>
> base:test - Runs the test suite.
>
> closedTests:test - Runs the test suite.
>
> controls:test - Runs the test suite.
>
> fxml:test - Runs the test suite.
>
> graphics:test - Runs the test suite.
>
> media:test - Runs the test suite.
>
> swing:test - Runs the test suite.
>
> swt:test - Runs the test suite.
>
> systemTests:test - Runs the test suite.
>
> web:test - Runs the test suite.
>
>
>
> *Other tasks*
>
> *-----------*
>
> all
>
> antUpdateCacheIfNeeded
>
> apps
>
> appsjar
>
> apps:appsJarMac
>
> media:buildMacGlib
>
> media:buildMacGStreamer
>
> media:buildMacNative
>
> media:buildMacPlugins
>
> buildModules
>
> media:buildNativeTargets
>
> checkCache
>
> chmodArtifactsSdkMac
>
> apps:cleanMac
>
> base:cleanOpenLegalStandaloneMac
>
> controls:cleanOpenLegalStandaloneMac
>
> fxml:cleanOpenLegalStandaloneMac
>
> graphics:cleanOpenLegalStandaloneMac
>
> media:cleanOpenLegalStandaloneMac
>
> swing:cleanOpenLegalStandaloneMac
>
> web:cleanOpenLegalStandaloneMac
>
> closedSystemTests
>
> graphics:compileDecoraCompilers - Compile the Decora JSL Compilers
>
> graphics:compileDecoraHLSLShaders - Compile Decora HLSL files into .obj
> files
>
> graphics:compileDecoraNativeShadersMac - Compiles Decora SSE natives for
> mac
>
> graphics:compileFullJava - Compile all of the graphics java classes -
> main and shaders
>
> base:compileJava - Compiles main Java source.
>
> closedTests:compileJava - Compiles main Java source.
>
> controls:compileJava - Compiles main Java source.
>
> fxml:compileJava - Compiles main Java source.
>
> graphics:compileJava - Compiles main Java source.
>
> media:compileJava - Compiles main Java source.
>
> swing:compileJava - Compiles main Java source.
>
> swt:compileJava - Compiles main Java source.
>
> systemTests:compileJava - Compiles main Java source.
>
> web:compileJava - Compiles main Java source.
>
> web:compileJavaDOMBinding
>
> web:compileJavaDOMBindingMac
>
> graphics:compileJslcJava - Compiles jslc Java source.
>
> web:compileNativeMac
>
> graphics:compilePrismCompilers - Compile the Prism JSL Compilers
>
> graphics:compilePrismHLSLShaders - Compile Prism HLSL files into .obj
> files
>
> graphics:compileShadersJava - Compiles shaders Java source.
>
> base:compileShimsJava - Compiles shims Java source.
>
> controls:compileShimsJava - Compiles shims Java source.
>
> fxml:compileShimsJava - Compiles shims Java source.
>
> graphics:compileShimsJava - Compiles shims Java source.
>
> swing:compileShimsJava - Compiles shims Java source.
>
> web:compileShimsJava - Compiles shims Java source.
>
> graphics:compileStubJava - Compiles stub Java source.
>
> systemTests:compileTestapp1Java - Compiles testapp1 Java source.
>
> systemTests:compileTestapp2Java - Compiles testapp2 Java source.
>
> systemTests:compileTestapp3Java - Compiles testapp3 Java source.
>
> systemTests:compileTestapp4Java - Compiles testapp4 Java source.
>
> systemTests:compileTestapp5Java - Compiles testapp5 Java source.
>
> systemTests:compileTestapp6Java - Compiles testapp6 Java source.
>
> systemTests:compileTestapp7Java - Compiles testapp7 Java source.
>
> base:compileTestJava - Compiles test Java source.
>
> closedTests:compileTestJava - Compiles test Java source.
>
> controls:compileTestJava - Compiles test Java source.
>
> fxml:compileTestJava - Compiles test Java source.
>
> graphics:compileTestJava - Compiles test Java source.
>
> media:compileTestJava - Compiles test Java source.
>
> swing:compileTestJava - Compiles test Java source.
>
> swt:compileTestJava - Compiles test Java source.
>
> systemTests:compileTestJava - Compiles test Java source.
>
> web:compileTestJava - Compiles test Java source.
>
> systemTests:compileTestscriptapp1Java - Compiles testscriptapp1 Java
> source.
>
> systemTests:compileTestscriptapp2Java - Compiles testscriptapp2 Java
> source.
>
> media:compileToolsJava - Compiles tools Java source.
>
> components - Displays the components produced by root project 'rt'.
> [deprecated]
>
> apps:components - Displays the components produced by project ':apps'.
> [deprecated]
>
> base:components - Displays the components produced by project ':base'.
> [deprecated]
>
> closedTests:components - Displays the components produced by project
> ':closedTests'. [deprecated]
>
> controls:components - Displays the components produced by project
> ':controls'. [deprecated]
>
> fxml:components - Displays the components produced by project ':fxml'.
> [deprecated]
>
> graphics:components - Displays the components produced by project
> ':graphics'. [deprecated]
>
> media:components - Displays the components produced by project ':media'.
> [deprecated]
>
> swing:components - Displays the components produced by project ':swing'.
> [deprecated]
>
> swt:components - Displays the components produced by project ':swt'.
> [deprecated]
>
> systemTests:components - Displays the components produced by project
> ':systemTests'. [deprecated]
>
> web:components - Displays the components produced by project ':web'.
> [deprecated]
>
> copyAppsArtifacts
>
> copyAppsArtifacts3DViewerMac
>
> copyAppsArtifactsEnsemble8Mac
>
> copyAppsArtifactsMac
>
> copyAppsArtifactsMandelbrotSetMac
>
> copyAppsArtifactsModenaMac
>
> copyAppsArtifactsProjectProperties3DViewerMac
>
> copyAppsArtifactsProjectPropertiesEnsemble8Mac
>
> copyAppsArtifactsProjectPropertiesMandelbrotSetMac
>
> copyAppsArtifactsProjectPropertiesModenaMac
>
> copyAppsArtifactsReadmeMac
>
> copyAppsArtifactsSources3DViewerMac
>
> copyAppsArtifactsSourcesEnsemble8Mac
>
> copyAppsArtifactsSourcesMandelbrotSetMac
>
> copyAppsArtifactsSourcesModenaMac
>
> copyArtifactsDocsMac
>
> copyArtifactsJmodsMac
>
> copyArtifactsSdkMac
>
> copyArtifactsToysCanvasTestMac
>
> copyArtifactsToysColorCubeMac
>
> copyArtifactsToysEarthCubeFX2Mac
>
> copyArtifactsToysEmbeddedSwingMac
>
> copyArtifactsToysFX8-3DAPIMac
>
> copyArtifactsToysGradientsMac
>
> copyArtifactsToysHelloMac
>
> copyArtifactsToysHelloWorldMac
>
> copyArtifactsToysMac
>
> copyArtifactsToysPickTest3DMac
>
> copyArtifactsToysRobotMac
>
> copyArtifactsToysVersionInfoMac
>
> copyArtifactsToysVideoCubeMac
>
> copyArtifactsToysZBufferTestMac
>
> base:copyBinFilesMac
>
> controls:copyBinFilesMac
>
> fxml:copyBinFilesMac
>
> graphics:copyBinFilesMac
>
> media:copyBinFilesMac
>
> swing:copyBinFilesMac
>
> web:copyBinFilesMac
>
> base:copyBuildPropertiesMac
>
> controls:copyBuildPropertiesMac
>
> fxml:copyBuildPropertiesMac
>
> graphics:copyBuildPropertiesMac
>
> media:copyBuildPropertiesMac
>
> swing:copyBuildPropertiesMac
>
> web:copyBuildPropertiesMac
>
> base:copyClassFilesMac
>
> controls:copyClassFilesMac
>
> fxml:copyClassFilesMac
>
> graphics:copyClassFilesMac
>
> media:copyClassFilesMac
>
> swing:copyClassFilesMac
>
> web:copyClassFilesMac
>
> base:copyClosedLegalStandaloneMac
>
> controls:copyClosedLegalStandaloneMac
>
> fxml:copyClosedLegalStandaloneMac
>
> graphics:copyClosedLegalStandaloneMac
>
> media:copyClosedLegalStandaloneMac
>
> swing:copyClosedLegalStandaloneMac
>
> web:copyClosedLegalStandaloneMac
>
> base:copyDocFilesMac
>
> controls:copyDocFilesMac
>
> fxml:copyDocFilesMac
>
> graphics:copyDocFilesMac
>
> media:copyDocFilesMac
>
> swing:copyDocFilesMac
>
> web:copyDocFilesMac
>
> web:copyDumpTreeNativeMac
>
> base:copyGeneratedShims
>
> controls:copyGeneratedShims
>
> fxml:copyGeneratedShims
>
> graphics:copyGeneratedShims
>
> swing:copyGeneratedShims
>
> web:copyGeneratedShims
>
> web:copyICUFile
>
> base:copyLegalMac
>
> controls:copyLegalMac
>
> fxml:copyLegalMac
>
> graphics:copyLegalMac
>
> media:copyLegalMac
>
> swing:copyLegalMac
>
> web:copyLegalMac
>
> base:copyLegalStandaloneMac
>
> controls:copyLegalStandaloneMac
>
> fxml:copyLegalStandaloneMac
>
> graphics:copyLegalStandaloneMac
>
> media:copyLegalStandaloneMac
>
> swing:copyLegalStandaloneMac
>
> web:copyLegalStandaloneMac
>
> base:copyLibFilesMac
>
> controls:copyLibFilesMac
>
> fxml:copyLibFilesMac
>
> graphics:copyLibFilesMac
>
> media:copyLibFilesMac
>
> swing:copyLibFilesMac
>
> web:copyLibFilesMac
>
> base:copyLibFilesStandaloneMac
>
> controls:copyLibFilesStandaloneMac
>
> fxml:copyLibFilesStandaloneMac
>
> graphics:copyLibFilesStandaloneMac
>
> media:copyLibFilesStandaloneMac
>
> swing:copyLibFilesStandaloneMac
>
> web:copyLibFilesStandaloneMac
>
> base:copyNativeFilesStandaloneMac
>
> controls:copyNativeFilesStandaloneMac
>
> fxml:copyNativeFilesStandaloneMac
>
> graphics:copyNativeFilesStandaloneMac
>
> media:copyNativeFilesStandaloneMac
>
> swing:copyNativeFilesStandaloneMac
>
> web:copyNativeFilesStandaloneMac
>
> web:copyNativeMac
>
> web:copyPreGeneratedWrappers
>
> controls:copyShimBss
>
> base:copySourceFilesMac
>
> controls:copySourceFilesMac
>
> fxml:copySourceFilesMac
>
> graphics:copySourceFilesMac
>
> media:copySourceFilesMac
>
> swing:copySourceFilesMac
>
> web:copySourceFilesMac
>
> systemTests:copyTestapp2
>
> systemTests:copyTestapp3
>
> systemTests:copyTestapp4
>
> systemTests:copyTestapp5
>
> systemTests:copyTestapp6
>
> systemTests:copyTestapp7
>
> systemTests:copyTestscriptapp1
>
> systemTests:copyTestscriptapp2
>
> copyToArtifactsBundledSDKMac
>
> copyToArtifactsDocsApiMac
>
> copyToArtifactsExportsMac
>
> copyToArtifactsStandaloneSDKMac
>
> copyToArtifactsTestMac
>
> copyToysToArtifactsMac
>
> systemTests:createTestapp1Jar1
>
> systemTests:createTestapp1Jar2
>
> systemTests:createTestApps
>
> createTestArgfiles
>
> createTestArgfilesMac
>
> dependentComponents - Displays the dependent components of components in
> root project 'rt'. [deprecated]
>
> apps:dependentComponents - Displays the dependent components of
> components in project ':apps'. [deprecated]
>
> base:dependentComponents - Displays the dependent components of
> components in project ':base'. [deprecated]
>
> closedTests:dependentComponents - Displays the dependent components of
> components in project ':closedTests'. [deprecated]
>
> controls:dependentComponents - Displays the dependent components of
> components in project ':controls'. [deprecated]
>
> fxml:dependentComponents - Displays the dependent components of
> components in project ':fxml'. [deprecated]
>
> graphics:dependentComponents - Displays the dependent components of
> components in project ':graphics'. [deprecated]
>
> media:dependentComponents - Displays the dependent components of
> components in project ':media'. [deprecated]
>
> swing:dependentComponents - Displays the dependent components of
> components in project ':swing'. [deprecated]
>
> swt:dependentComponents - Displays the dependent components of components
> in project ':swt'. [deprecated]
>
> systemTests:dependentComponents - Displays the dependent components of
> components in project ':systemTests'. [deprecated]
>
> web:dependentComponents - Displays the dependent components of components
> in project ':web'. [deprecated]
>
> downloadJdkDocs
>
> web:drtJar
>
> findbugs
>
> graphics:generateDecoraShaders - Generate Decora shaders from JSL
>
> graphics:generateGrammarSource
>
> media:generateMediaErrorHeader
>
> graphics:generatePrismShaders - Generate Prism shaders from JSL
>
> apps:getLucene
>
> graphics:initShaderDirs
>
> jdkZip
>
> jmods
>
> graphics:linkDecoraNativeShadersMac - Creates native dynamic library for
> Decora SSE mac
>
> closedTests:manualTest
>
> mkdirArtifactsMac
>
> mkdirBundledSDKMac
>
> mkdirStandaloneSDKMac
>
> model - Displays the configuration model of root project 'rt'.
> [deprecated]
>
> apps:model - Displays the configuration model of project ':apps'.
> [deprecated]
>
> base:model - Displays the configuration model of project ':base'.
> [deprecated]
>
> closedTests:model - Displays the configuration model of project
> ':closedTests'. [deprecated]
>
> controls:model - Displays the configuration model of project ':controls'.
> [deprecated]
>
> fxml:model - Displays the configuration model of project ':fxml'.
> [deprecated]
>
> graphics:model - Displays the configuration model of project ':graphics'.
> [deprecated]
>
> media:model - Displays the configuration model of project ':media'.
> [deprecated]
>
> swing:model - Displays the configuration model of project ':swing'.
> [deprecated]
>
> swt:model - Displays the configuration model of project ':swt'.
> [deprecated]
>
> systemTests:model - Displays the configuration model of project
> ':systemTests'. [deprecated]
>
> web:model - Displays the configuration model of project ':web'.
> [deprecated]
>
> base:modularJarStandaloneMac
>
> controls:modularJarStandaloneMac
>
> fxml:modularJarStandaloneMac
>
> graphics:modularJarStandaloneMac
>
> media:modularJarStandaloneMac
>
> swing:modularJarStandaloneMac
>
> web:modularJarStandaloneMac
>
> base:modularPublicationJarMac
>
> controls:modularPublicationJarMac
>
> fxml:modularPublicationJarMac
>
> graphics:modularPublicationJarMac
>
> media:modularPublicationJarMac
>
> swing:modularPublicationJarMac
>
> web:modularPublicationJarMac
>
> base:moduleEmptyPublicationJarMac
>
> controls:moduleEmptyPublicationJarMac
>
> fxml:moduleEmptyPublicationJarMac
>
> graphics:moduleEmptyPublicationJarMac
>
> media:moduleEmptyPublicationJarMac
>
> swing:moduleEmptyPublicationJarMac
>
> web:moduleEmptyPublicationJarMac
>
> perf
>
> prepareKotlinBuildScriptModel
>
> prepOpenJfxStubs
>
> graphics:processDecoraShaders - Copy hlsl / frag shaders to
> build/resources/jsl-decora
>
> graphics:processDecoraShimsShaders - Copy hlsl / frag shaders to shims
>
> graphics:processJslcResources - Processes jslc resources.
>
> graphics:processPrismShaders - Copy hlsl / frag shaders to
> build/resources/jsl-prism
>
> graphics:processPrismShimsShaders - Copy hlsl / frag shaders to shims
>
> base:processResources - Processes main resources.
>
> closedTests:processResources - Processes main resources.
>
> controls:processResources - Processes main resources.
>
> fxml:processResources - Processes main resources.
>
> graphics:processResources - Processes main resources.
>
> media:processResources - Processes main resources.
>
> swing:processResources - Processes main resources.
>
> swt:processResources - Processes main resources.
>
> systemTests:processResources - Processes main resources.
>
> web:processResources - Processes main resources.
>
> graphics:processShaders
>
> graphics:processShadersResources - Processes shaders resources.
>
> base:processShimsResources - Processes shims resources.
>
> controls:processShimsResources - Processes shims resources.
>
> fxml:processShimsResources - Processes shims resources.
>
> graphics:processShimsResources - Processes shims resources.
>
> swing:processShimsResources - Processes shims resources.
>
> web:processShimsResources - Processes shims resources.
>
> graphics:processShimsShaders
>
> graphics:processStubResources - Processes stub resources.
>
> systemTests:processTestapp1Resources - Processes testapp1 resources.
>
> systemTests:processTestapp2Resources - Processes testapp2 resources.
>
> systemTests:processTestapp3Resources - Processes testapp3 resources.
>
> systemTests:processTestapp4Resources - Processes testapp4 resources.
>
> systemTests:processTestapp5Resources - Processes testapp5 resources.
>
> systemTests:processTestapp6Resources - Processes testapp6 resources.
>
> systemTests:processTestapp7Resources - Processes testapp7 resources.
>
> base:processTestResources - Processes test resources.
>
> closedTests:processTestResources - Processes test resources.
>
> controls:processTestResources - Processes test resources.
>
> fxml:processTestResources - Processes test resources.
>
> graphics:processTestResources - Processes test resources.
>
> media:processTestResources - Processes test resources.
>
> swing:processTestResources - Processes test resources.
>
> swt:processTestResources - Processes test resources.
>
> systemTests:processTestResources - Processes test resources.
>
> web:processTestResources - Processes test resources.
>
> systemTests:processTestscriptapp1Resources - Processes testscriptapp1
> resources.
>
> systemTests:processTestscriptapp2Resources - Processes testscriptapp2
> resources.
>
> media:processToolsResources - Processes tools resources.
>
> base:processVersionInfo - Replace params in VersionInfo and copy file to
> destination
>
> publicExports
>
> sdk
>
> shims
>
> showFlags
>
> showFlagsMAC
>
> systemTests:systemTestSetup
>
> testAntImport
>
> web:testWebArchiveJar
>
> updateCacheIfNeeded
>
> base:validateSourceSets
>
> controls:validateSourceSets
>
> fxml:validateSourceSets
>
> graphics:validateSourceSets
>
> media:validateSourceSets
>
> swing:validateSourceSets
>
> swt:validateSourceSets
>
> systemTests:validateSourceSets
>
> web:validateSourceSets
>
> verifyJava
>
> zipDocsMac
>
> zipJmodsMac
>
> zips
>
> zipSdkMac
>
> zipSourceFilesStandaloneMac
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
> *From: *Nir Lisker <nlisker at gmail.com>
> *Date: *Tuesday, June 18, 2024 at 17:30
> *To: *Thiago Milczarek Sayão <thiago.sayao at gmail.com>
> *Cc: *Andy Goryachev <andy.goryachev at oracle.com>, openjfx-dev at openjdk.org
> <openjfx-dev at openjdk.org>
> *Subject: *[External] : Re: Eclipse and Gradle in OpenJFX
>
> It has been a while since I tried a clean import of jfx, but the
> instructions in
> https://wiki.openjdk.org/display/OpenJFX/Using+an+IDE#UsinganIDE-UsingEclipse
> seem correct, unless something changed. What you describe is written there.
> Only the initial import requires a gradle build, and after reverting the
> project and classpath changes, you can work with ECJ (unless you need tasks
> to build native code etc.)
>
>
>
> What is worth looking at is the 'eclipse' gradle task that tries to
> generate these files according to the gradle files. However, the way the
> project is built in gradle is both complicated and very old (compliant with
> gradle 2 I think), so I don't know how well that will work. In my modern
> projects, the 'eclipse' task works really well and allows me to not check
> in the eclipse files: a gradle refresh/synch is run once (does all the
> configuration and dependency management), and then running 'eclipse' once
> sets up the eclipse side.
>
>
>
> On Tue, Jun 18, 2024 at 10:52 PM Thiago Milczarek Sayão <
> thiago.sayao at gmail.com> wrote:
>
> Andy,
>
>
>
> We kind of did the opposite for Intellij (got rid of the .iml files and
> went for gradle import):
>
>
>
> https://github.com/openjdk/jfx/pull/1009
> <https://urldefense.com/v3/__https:/github.com/openjdk/jfx/pull/1009__;!!ACWV5N9M2RV99hQ!OQBGG5BAFNNepw6XwqGaLl-tjDL2GebWmVZkP3DS7eWwP19RqhTk4SP9hTCUQo-sH4MO_4i6qRMHC-LWytVl$>
>
>
>
> I couldn't get it to detect the manual tests tho. Changing some gradle
> files worked, but would require a deeper review, so we went without it.
>
>
>
> -- Thiago.
>
>
>
> Em ter., 18 de jun. de 2024 às 16:05, Andy Goryachev <
> andy.goryachev at oracle.com> escreveu:
>
> Dear developers:
>
>
>
> Does anyone use gradle in Eclipse (Buildship plug-in) with the OpenJFX
> repo?
>
>
>
> The reason I am asking is that in my experience, the gradle nature in
> OpenJFX is either misconfigured, or obsolete, or both.  There is a rather
> old wiki page [0] which describes the Eclipse setup, though I don't think
> it is correct anymore.  The initial import of the repository in Eclipse
> triggers an internal gradle run which creates/modifies a bunch of
> .classpath and .project files which must be undone before the workspace
> becomes usable.  In any case, only a proper command line gradle build is
> supported anyway.
>
>
>
> I would like to propose removing the gradle nature from Eclipse's .project
> files in OpenJFX.  Once done, the projects can be trivially imported into a
> new workspace with no extra steps required.  This change has no impact on
> command line build whatsoever.
>
>
>
> What do you think?
>
>
>
> Thank you
>
> -andy
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
> *References*
>
>
>
> [1]
> https://wiki.openjdk.org/display/OpenJFX/Using+an+IDE#UsinganIDE-ConfigureEclipsetousethelatestJDK
>
>
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <https://mail.openjdk.org/pipermail/openjfx-dev/attachments/20240707/de671779/attachment-0001.htm>