From damjan.jov at gmail.com  Mon May 30 02:30:53 2011
From: damjan.jov at gmail.com (Damjan Jovanovic)
Date: Mon, 30 May 2011 11:30:53 +0200
Subject: <Sound Dev> JDK6 doesn't see the "default" ALSA device,
 preventing sound card sharing with other applications?
Message-ID: <BANLkTin3_2iN5FPNtxOB=ftVWAY=Y09WpQ@mail.gmail.com>

Hi

On Linux, JDK6 doesn't show/use the "default" ALSA device. By
comparison, this device is shown and used by OpenJDK. The "default"
device is the only device capable of properly sharing access to the
sound card with other native applications, so it's pretty vital.

My investigation is detailed below:

Sound card:
00:1b.0 Audio device: Intel Corporation 82801I (ICH9 Family) HD Audio
Controller (rev 03)

JDK = JDK 1.6.0_22 on x86 Linux
OpenJDK = OpenJDK7 19.0-b06 on same x86 Linux

JDK's /META-INF/services/javax.sound.sampled.spi.MixerProvider:
com.sun.media.sound.PortMixerProvider
com.sun.media.sound.SimpleInputDeviceProvider
com.sun.media.sound.HeadspaceMixerProvider
com.sun.media.sound.DirectAudioDeviceProvider

OpenJDK's /META-INF/services/javax.sound.sampled.spi.MixerProvider:
com.sun.media.sound.PortMixerProvider
com.sun.media.sound.DirectAudioDeviceProvider

JDK's mixer list:
"Intel [plughw:0,0], version 1.0.21"
"Intel [plughw:0,3], version 1.0.21"
"Java Sound Audio Engine, version 1.0"
"Port Intel [hw:0], version 1.0.21"

OpenJDK's mixer list:
"default [default], version 1.0.21"
"Intel [plughw:0,0], version 1.0.21"
"Intel [plughw:0,3], version 1.0.21"
"Port Intel [hw:0], version 1.0.21"

Here we have 5 distinct mixers, 3 of which are common to both JDK and
OpenJDK. Now testing them with the following conditions:
* audio format is "AudioFormat audioFormat = new
AudioFormat(AudioFormat.Encoding.PCM_SIGNED, 8000, 16, 1, 2, 8000,
true);"
* 3 cases are tested: pasuspender is used to bypass PulseAudio,
PulseAudio is active with no other sound playing, and PulseAudio
active with VLC playing sound through its PulseAudio output module
during the test
* AudioSystem.getSourceDataLine(audioFormat, mixerInfo) is tested, and
if that succeeds, open(audioFormat, 2*8*60*3) on that sourceDataLine
is tested

The following results are obtained for each mixer:

"default [default]" (description: Direct Audio Device: default,
default, default)
Only available in OpenJDK
OpenJDK + pasuspender: AudioSystem.getSourceDataLine() succeeds, open() succeeds
OpenJDK + no other sound: AudioSystem.getSourceDataLine() succeeds,
open() succeeds
OpenJDK + VLC playing sound: AudioSystem.getSourceDataLine() succeeds,
open() succeeds
In other words, this mixer works perfectly.

"Intel [plughw:0,0], version 1.0.21" (description: Direct Audio
Device: HDA Intel, AD198x Analog, AD198x Analog)
JDK + pasuspender: AudioSystem.getSourceDataLine() succeeds, open() succeeds
OpenJDK + pasuspender: AudioSystem.getSourceDataLine() succeeds, open() succeeds
JDK + no other sound: AudioSystem.getSourceDataLine() succeeds, open() succeeds
OpenJDK + no other sound: AudioSystem.getSourceDataLine() throws
"java.lang.IllegalArgumentException: Line unsupported: ..."
JDK + VLC playing sound: AudioSystem.getSourceDataLine() throws
"java.lang.IllegalArgumentException: Line unsupported: ..."
OpenJDK + VLC playing sound: AudioSystem.getSourceDataLine() throws
"java.lang.IllegalArgumentException: Line unsupported: ..."

"Intel [plughw:0,3], version 1.0.21" (description: Direct Audio
Device: HDA Intel, INTEL HDMI, INTEL HDMI)
JDK + pasuspender: AudioSystem.getSourceDataLine() succeeds, open() succeeds
OpenJDK + pasuspender: AudioSystem.getSourceDataLine() succeeds, open() succeeds
JDK + no other sound: AudioSystem.getSourceDataLine() succeeds, open() succeeds
OpenJDK + no other sound: AudioSystem.getSourceDataLine() succeeds,
open() succeeds
JDK + VLC playing sound: AudioSystem.getSourceDataLine() succeeds,
open() succeeds
OpenJDK + VLC playing sound: AudioSystem.getSourceDataLine() succeeds,
open() succeeds

"Java Sound Audio Engine, version 1.0" (description: Software mixer
and synthesizer)
Only available in JDK
JDK + pasuspender: AudioSystem.getSourceDataLine() succeeds, open() succeeds
JDK + no other sound: AudioSystem.getSourceDataLine() succeeds, open() succeeds
JDK + VLC playing sound: AudioSystem.getSourceDataLine() succeeds, open() throws
      "javax.sound.sampled.LineUnavailableException: Audio Device Unavailable"

"Port Intel [hw:0], version 1.0.21" (description: HDA Intel, Intel G45 DEVCTG)
JDK + pasuspender: AudioSystem.getSourceDataLine() throws
"java.lang.IllegalArgumentException: Line unsupported: ..."
OpenJDK + pasuspender: AudioSystem.getSourceDataLine() throws
"java.lang.IllegalArgumentException: Line unsupported: ..."
JDK + no other sound: AudioSystem.getSourceDataLine() throws
"java.lang.IllegalArgumentException: Line unsupported: ..."
OpenJDK + no other sound: AudioSystem.getSourceDataLine() throws
"java.lang.IllegalArgumentException: Line unsupported: ..."
JDK + VLC playing sound: AudioSystem.getSourceDataLine() throws
"java.lang.IllegalArgumentException: Line unsupported: ..."
OpenJDK + VLC playing sound: AudioSystem.getSourceDataLine() throws
"java.lang.IllegalArgumentException: Line unsupported: ..."


Also, while VLC is playing audio:
* In JDK, AudioSystem.getSourceDataLine(audioFormat) succeeds, but
open() throws an exception
* In OpenJDK, AudioSystem.getSourceDataLine(audioFormat) succeeds, and
open() succeeds

The above carnage amounts to:
* In JDK, sound is completely unusable with any other application playing sound
* In OpenJDK, at least one SourceDataLine - the default one called
"default [default]" - works well even with other applications playing
sound

The lack of the "default" device in JDK6 is strange, since
jdk/src/solaris/native/com/sun/media/sound/PLATFORM_API_LinuxOS_ALSA_PCMUtils.c
seems to have had it since the initial import in revision
0c738a3e5791.

$ strings openjdk7/build/linux-i586/j2sdk-image/jre/lib/i386/libjsoundalsa.so
| grep default
default
$ strings jdk6/jre/lib/i386/libjsoundalsa.so | grep default
(nothing)

So it looks like there's some vital patch that adds support for the
"default" ALSA device that hasn't been applied to JDK6.

My tests on jre-7-ea-bin-b144-linux-i586-26_may_2011.tar.gz from
http://jdk7.java.net show that it does see the "default" device, but
even the latest jdk1.6.0_25 doesn't see it, so this bug seems specific
to JDK6/JRE6.

So please can you add the "default" device to JDK6?

Thank you
Damjan Jovanovic

P.S. Out of interest, why is the "default" device necessary? Java
opens most ALSA devices with the "plughw:" prefix, which is "plug"
(ALSA does sample conversions in user-space) and "hw" together (direct
hardware access, locking out other applications unless the sound card
supports hardware mixing). The "default" device is special-cased, and
opened without a "plughw:" prefix. In addition, with PulseAudio
installed, most Linux distributions make the "default" device go
through PulseAudio, which does high quality resampling and mixing, and
allows multiple applications to share access to sound hardware.

From omajid at redhat.com  Mon May 30 06:47:57 2011
From: omajid at redhat.com (Omair Majid)
Date: Mon, 30 May 2011 09:47:57 -0400
Subject: <Sound Dev> JDK6 doesn't see the "default" ALSA device,
 preventing sound card sharing with other applications?
In-Reply-To: <BANLkTin3_2iN5FPNtxOB=ftVWAY=Y09WpQ@mail.gmail.com>
References: <BANLkTin3_2iN5FPNtxOB=ftVWAY=Y09WpQ@mail.gmail.com>
Message-ID: <4DE3A00D.8030103@redhat.com>

On 05/30/2011 05:30 AM, Damjan Jovanovic wrote:
> Hi
>
> On Linux, JDK6 doesn't show/use the "default" ALSA device. By
> comparison, this device is shown and used by OpenJDK. The "default"
> device is the only device capable of properly sharing access to the
> sound card with other native applications, so it's pretty vital.
>

You may find this OpenJDK bug report relevant:
https://bugs.openjdk.java.net/show_bug.cgi?id=100043

Unfortunately, there is nothing I can do to fix the proprietary JDK6.

If you don't mind me asking, is there any particular reason you are 
using the proprietary JDK and not OpenJDK6/IcedTea6?

Thanks,
Omair

From damjan.jov at gmail.com  Mon May 30 08:00:39 2011
From: damjan.jov at gmail.com (Damjan Jovanovic)
Date: Mon, 30 May 2011 17:00:39 +0200
Subject: <Sound Dev> JDK6 doesn't see the "default" ALSA device,
 preventing sound card sharing with other applications?
In-Reply-To: <4DE3A00D.8030103@redhat.com>
References: <BANLkTin3_2iN5FPNtxOB=ftVWAY=Y09WpQ@mail.gmail.com>
	<4DE3A00D.8030103@redhat.com>
Message-ID: <BANLkTi=frB41=a2ZwTCoPdmJ34jR6XwvFA@mail.gmail.com>

On Mon, May 30, 2011 at 3:47 PM, Omair Majid <omajid at redhat.com> wrote:
> On 05/30/2011 05:30 AM, Damjan Jovanovic wrote:
>>
>> Hi
>>
>> On Linux, JDK6 doesn't show/use the "default" ALSA device. By
>> comparison, this device is shown and used by OpenJDK. The "default"
>> device is the only device capable of properly sharing access to the
>> sound card with other native applications, so it's pretty vital.
>>
>
> You may find this OpenJDK bug report relevant:
> https://bugs.openjdk.java.net/show_bug.cgi?id=100043
>
> Unfortunately, there is nothing I can do to fix the proprietary JDK6.
>
> If you don't mind me asking, is there any particular reason you are using
> the proprietary JDK and not OpenJDK6/IcedTea6?
>
> Thanks,
> Omair
>

Well I want my application to work for other Linux users who might
only have the proprietary JDK. Also a pulse-java.jar bug makes
recording sound in IcedTea and at least Ubuntu's OpenJDK package
completely unusable for me so I can't recommend that either:
http://icedtea.classpath.org/bugzilla/show_bug.cgi?id=734

Thank you
Damjan Jovanovic